By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Super Mario Sunshine vs Super Mario 3D World

 

Which one is teh bestest?

Sunshine 75 36.41%
 
3D World 105 50.97%
 
Call of D- I mean see results 25 12.14%
 
Total:205
Dusk on 17 June 2014
Nintentacle said:

I chose to do these game because they're on the two lowest-selling Nintendo consoles, and they're review scores are practically the same. Which one do you think is better?

I have to pick 3D World by default, since I haven't played Sunshine.


Entirely different games with completely different play mechanics. Both are very good games. I would say I prefer 3D world better, but that's just my perference out of the two. 



Gotta figure out how to set these up lol.

Around the Network
curl-6 on 17 June 2014

3D World by so much it's not even funny.

Sunshine was garbage.



archbrix on 17 June 2014

3D World.



leedlelee on 17 June 2014
curl-6 said:
3D World by so much it's not even funny.

Sunshine was garbage.

I agree...

The blue coins were the most disgracefully lazy feature I've ever seen in a Nintendo game...

They may as well have outright said that they didn't have time to finish the game, as Sunshine was quite blatantly an unfinished product...



Have a nice day...

TheLastStarFighter on 17 June 2014

I"ve never played Sunshine, but I can't imagine any possible way it's even close to 3DW based on gameplay videos I've seen of it.



Around the Network
Nintentacle on 17 June 2014
RolStoppable said:

but desperate Nintendo actually puts out games that clearly should have been delayed.

Well, someone forgot Pikmin 3, TW101, and Donkey Kong.

Although, I do get the vibe Mario Kart 7 and 8 were a little rushed...



FarleyMcFirefly on 17 June 2014

I really disliked Sunshine, 3D World Is phenomenal!



1doesnotsimply

leedlelee on 17 June 2014
RolStoppable said:
leedlelee said:
curl-6 said:
3D World by so much it's not even funny.

Sunshine was garbage.

I agree...

The blue coins were the most disgracefully lazy feature I've ever seen in a Nintendo game...

They may as well have outright said that they didn't have time to finish the game, as Sunshine was quite blatantly an unfinished product...

Aren't you forgetting about the sea in The Wind Waker? Same story (stretch the length of an incomplete game), different flavor.

There are people who say that desperate Nintendo is the best Nintendo, but desperate Nintendo actually puts out games that clearly should have been delayed. The GC was in trouble (just like the N64 before), so Nintendo cut corners to spur sales quicker (just like with Mario Kart 64 and Yoshi's Story).

You're absolutely right...

While there were things in WW to praise, the largely empty sea and the Triforce fetch quest failed to hide the fact that the game was short at least one dungeon...

Even if made by Nintendo, a rushed game is still a rushed game...

I will concede that WW definitely feels more finished than Sunshine...



Have a nice day...

SjOne on 17 June 2014

Sunshine had a larger influence while 3D World made my dream of co-op come true



Never on 17 June 2014

Sunshine had it issues but it was a wonderful game. It was the nearest thing we got to a Mario 64 sequel. But it had larger and more elaborate levels, an even more complex set of moves to pull off and a difficulty level that seemed suited to someone who'd already collected all 120 Mario 64 stars. The camera was poor and there was a roughness to it, but that didn't take away what a terrific game it was.

Mario 3d world didn't feel fresh to me after playing 3d land. I had lots of fun with it and the multiplayer was great but I felt no sense of love for the game. Once it was over I quickly forgot all about it. Something that's never happened to me before in regards to a 3d Mario game.