By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Nintendo E3 elimination game closed! Thanks for Playing!

t3mporary_126 on 13 June 2014
Pavolink said:

Scoretable:

After calculating to SuperWatch111s post in page 3 (page containing 25 posts):

Zelda U (61 points) 

X: Xenoblade Chronicles (48 points) 

Splatoon (35 points)

 Super Smash Bros. 4 Wii U (24 points) 

Bayonetta 1+2 (21 points)

Hyrule Warriors (18 points)

Captain Toad Treasure Tracker (19 points)

Yoshi's Wolly World (15 points)

Mario Maker (12 points)

Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney Trilogy (11 points)

Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright (10 points)

Super Smash Bros. 4 3DS (6 points) 

Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate (10 points)

One Piece Unlimted 3DS (10 points)

Theatrhythm Final Fantasy Curtain Call (10 points)

Fantasy Life (11 points)

Fossi Fighters Frontier (4 points)

Pokemon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire (7 points)

LEGO Batman 3 (0 points)

Mario vs Donkey Kong (6 points)

Project STEAM (8 points)

Art Academy Wii U (3 points)

Pokemon Art Academy (0 points)

Devil's Third (0 points)

 

UPDATED to LemonSlice post

Thanks for taking your time to update the score table! I was quite busy earlier. Now that I'm back home on pc, I can get cracking on these scores!

Cobretti2 said:
oh look zelda is winning surprise surprise. and people wonder why 3rd part dont want to make games for Nintendo system. Most those other games show MUCH more game content than Zelda and people just being bias here lol.

Thanks for participating and I respect your opinion but please do not foster a sensitive topics about third parties on Nintendo system in this sort of thread. 



Around the Network
t3mporary_126 on 13 June 2014

If anyone is interested in posting an updated score table when I have not for an hour or two, feel free to do so! I ask you to keep a specific format though  

For example look at my quote below and read the **(comments)** to the side

t3mporary_126 said:

Elimination Update: **(Add this if a game has been eliminated in your calculations)**

Lego batman, pokemon art academy, and devil's third are eliminated  **(and add the games eliminated here)**

Scoretable: (18:25 PTD)  **(You don't have to add a time stamp. If you do, please use military time "0:00-23:59 ???")**

After calculating to NintendoMonkey33's post in page 3 (page containing 25 posts): **(You must view threads in 25 post per page to get this page number info correct. And make sure you add the username! It indicates that was the last person included in your calculations)**

Zelda U (73 points) (If you have time, please put the highest ranked game on top and the lowest on bottom)

X: Xenoblade Chronicles 55 points +2 = (57 points) **(Bolded Underline for Increased rankings)**

Splatoon 36 - 3= (33 points) **(Bolded Italicized for Decreased rankings!)**

 Super Smash Bros. 4 Wii U (35 points) 

Bayonetta 1+2 (28 points)

Yoshi's Wolly World 18 - 1 = (17  points)

Hyrule Warriors (16 points)

Captain Toad Treasure Tracker (15 points)

Fantasy Life 11+3=(14 points)

Mario Maker (12 points)

Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney Trilogy (11 points)

Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright (10 points)

Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate (10 points)

Project STEAM (7 points)

 One Piece Unlimted 3DS (6 points)

Mario vs Donkey Kong 6 - 2 = (4 points) 

Super Smash Bros. 4 3DS 3+1= (4  points) 

Pokemon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire (3 points)

 Art Academy Wii U (1 points)

Voting on an eliminated game will not move that game back up or into a negative number. Please be aware when games are eliminated when I post an update about them! **(keep this message up in case people don't know!)**

If a game is eliminated, you don't need to list their score or cross its name. Put it under the Elimination update.

If you have any questions regarding this, let me know! Thanks for participating and have fun rating!  



DolPhanTendo on 14 June 2014

Really disappointed Devil's Third didnt get the love it deserves. The online multiplayer shooter will finally have something new thanks to this game and most people just pooped on it because..." OMG the Graphics!!"



Cobretti2 on 14 June 2014
Samus Aran said:
Cobretti2 said:
oh look zelda is winning surprise surprise. and people wonder why 3rd part dont want to make games for Nintendo system. Most those other games show MUCH more game content than Zelda and people just being bias here lol.

You're kidding right? Which third party game on this list shows more content than a typical Zelda game? 

devils third had more content. Even the other Nintendo games had more content like splatoon. Zelda had just a short trailer. 

The point I am making their is bias already in the vote and all this from a short trailer which just confirms most Nintendo fans don't care for 3rd party as pretty much all of them are now eliminated.  

 



 

 

Noshowers on 14 June 2014

Ok, taking a shot at this (and trying not to use eliminated games:)

Super Smash Bros. 4 (Wii U) +3
Zelda U +2
Hyrule Warriors +1

Fossil Fighters Frontier -3
Theatrhythm Final Fantasy Curtain Call -2
Captain Toad Treasure Tracker -1



Around the Network
NintendoPie on 14 June 2014
Cobretti2 said:

devils third had more content. Even the other Nintendo games had more content like splatoon. Zelda had just a short trailer. 

The point I am making their is bias already in the vote and all this from a short trailer which just confirms most Nintendo fans don't care for 3rd party as pretty much all of them are now eliminated.  

 

No one's denying people by Nintendo consoles for Nintendo games. I mean, it makes sense when you think about it; Nintendo makes some of the best game in the industry. Third-parties that can live up to Nintendo games are noticed. (You know, like Bayonetta, which you failed to recognize is fairly high up in the list.)



curl-6 on 14 June 2014

UP:

Yoshi's Wooly World +3

Bayonetta 2 +2

Hyrule Warriors +1

 

DOWN:

Super Smash Bros 4 3DS -3

Super Smash Bros 4 Wii U -2

Pokemon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire -1



ibrahimman0 on 14 June 2014

X: Xenoblade Chronicles +3
Bayonetta 2 +2
Smash Bros WiiU +1
One piece unlimited 3ds -3
Fossil Fighters -2
Captain Toad -1



IMSM

t3mporary_126 on 14 June 2014

Recent Elimination Update:

Fossil Fighter and Theatrhythm Final Fantasy 

click on http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6413958 for other eliminated games posted in page 1, the second post.

Scoretable: (23:08 PTD)

After calculating to ibrahimman0 's post in page 4 (page containing 25 posts):

Zelda U (73 points) 

X: Xenoblade Chronicles (55 points) 

Splatoon (36 points)

 Super Smash Bros. 4 Wii U (35 points) 

Bayonetta 1+2 (28 points)

Yoshi's Wolly World (18 points)

Hyrule Warriors (16 points)

Captain Toad Treasure Tracker (15 points)

Mario Maker (12 points)

Phoenix Wright Ace Attorney Trilogy (11 points)

Professor Layton vs. Phoenix Wright (10 points)

Fantasy Life (11 points)

Monster Hunter 4 Ultimate (10 points)

Project STEAM (7 points)

 One Piece Unlimted 3DS (6 points)

Mario vs Donkey Kong (6 points) 

Pokemon Omega Ruby/Alpha Sapphire (3 points)

Super Smash Bros. 4 3DS (3 points) 

 Art Academy Wii U (1 points)

Thank you everyone for not rating eliminated games! Keep it up! 



t3mporary_126 on 14 June 2014

Quick announcement: I'm definitely not going to be on VGchartz for the next 6-8 hours (its the 23rd hour of the day in Western USA here!) so I won't be able to update on any eliminated games or score changes. 

However, if any of you are confident in calculating future ratings, click on http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=6416047 to follow my format and instructions in posting the scoretable. 

It might be difficult to track down all the ratings by simply looking at the posts so I recommend you jot down them down on another word document or notebook before putting any number in your scoretable post! Personally, I've been using a Google Drive Spreadsheet. You can view it here on https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/13PvQZ54iAvluysPzaSLVx8lRIE5N0Eu_HtSN8kwqBtM/edit#gid=0 and create your own if you like. Note you can only view my spreadsheet and not edit it!

Although I will be reviewing all calculations in the scoretables posted, any posted scoretables will help. Just make sure you read my instructions in that linked post!

Thanks for rating guys! Keep at it and have fun ! If you have any questions, I may answer them within the next hour.