I'm terrible at making lists, but

+Top 3

• Mass Effect
• Alan Wake
• Super Mario Galaxy

+Crap 3

Since I don't buy that many games it's hard for me to have 3 crappy games as I have to be selective with my purchases. With that said

• Prototype (Horrible and broken game, at least on PC)

Top 3:
Dragon's Dogma
The Last of Us
God of War 3

Bottom 3:
Metal Gear Solid 4
Valkyria Chronicles
Two Worlds 2

Top 3:
Uncharted 3
Last of Us
inFAMOUS 2

Crap 3
Every single AC game (Except Black Flag)
The Walking Dead
GTA IV

My worst 3:
1. FIFA 14
2. GTA Online
3. FIFA 13

Resident 6 even worse than 5? Wow. Need to play it, just for kicks.

Top 3:

- Final Fantasy XIII
- Call of Duty 4: Modern Warfare
- Tales of Vesperia

Crap 3:

- Bioshock
- Mass Effect
- Gears of War

(Well not exactly crap, I tend to avoid crap games completely.)

I think there needs to be a distinction between overrated and actually bad.

Top 3:
PW: AA: Trials and Tribulations
Metroid Prime 3: Corruption
Metal Gear Rising: Revengeance

Overrated 3:
Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword
The Last of Us

Bottom 3:
Assassin's Creed 3
Resident Evil 6
I'm sure I'll think of a third eventually

Interesting. You liked Revengeance that much? I actually loved that game, but I never thought I'd see it in someone's favourite games of the whole gen.

Top 3

God of War III
Mass Effect 2
Red Dead Redemption

Overrated/Crap

Metal Gear Solid 4 (Crap)
Skyrim (Overrated, still like it a lot)
GTA IV (Overrated)

Top 3:
Uncharted 2
Metal Gear Solid Peace Walker
The Last of Us

Crap 3:
Resident Evil 6
Mindjack
All of the Call of Duty games