I prefered 3 - DESERT DRAKE!

Uncharted 2 for me.

Loved all three, for all different reasons. Uncharted came out when I first got my Ps3, so it's the first AAA game I played on it. Great game and story, with a weird ending twist. However.... Uncharted 2 completely overhauled the first game in two short years, showing developers all over how to really make a sequel. Naughty Dog, in my opinion, proved with U2 how to make not just a sequel, but a classic and almost perfect game. While introducing multiplayer into an even IMPROVED story??? DAMNN GURLL.

U3 was a great game, don't get me wrong. But something about the story felt too familiar..... If released at the same time, I'm sure U3 would get the nod as the greater game. But U2 did more to differentiate itself from it's previous entry, and that's why it's one of the best games of this generation.

U2 and TLoU would be a damn good start... but warning if you dont space out the awesomeness there might not be much to look forward to later (besides GoW3).

OT: I chose two because it was a huge leap from one in all the right directions (unlike resistance). It had more impact since three was as good as 2 but since it was coming from 2 it didnt have the same aweness to it

Picked Uncharted 2. Its not only my favorite exclusive but also my favorite game that has come out for the PS3 just ahead of MGS4.

I would go with uncharted 2

67 people voted on the wrong game so far.

Uncharted 3 is the correct answer.  In my opinion, atleast.

You should really have see the results option. I hate to choose between Uncharted 2 and 3 so I'm not going to.

I don't really get the point of all these threads, the answer is Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

The most special game I have ever played, if I (start and) finish Beyond in time, I'll be playing it as my last PS3 game just before I get my PS4

very tough choice.

Uncharted 2 had the better campaign, with better pacing, and set pieces that made sense in the context of the story. it also had the better villian. Its multiplayer was great, but not as great as Uncharted 3. But it also made a huge jump in quality over its already impressive predecessor: Uncharted 1.

Uncharted 3 on the other hand. very high quality as well, but didnt seem quite as polished some how. the story wasnt as good as 2's, and the set pieces, though amazing, seemed forced in the context of the story. The villian and final boss fight wasnt as good as U2. But the gameplay was the best in the series, which is saying a lot since uncharted games have great gameplay already. Also the multiplayer improved dramatically what was already amazing multi.

my choice goes to.....
Uncharted 3