By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Battlefield 4 PS4/Xbox One Direct Feed Footage Coming October the 29th, One Version “Looks Better than the Other”

attaboy on 25 October 2013

Copied from the OP: Battlefield 4 PS4/Xbox One Direct Feed Footage Coming October the 29th, One Version “Looks Better than the Other”

Notice the capitol "O" when it says "One Version". Xbox One, obviously.



Around the Network
ethomaz on 25 October 2013

The two comments are unrelated... He is promoting two places with (twitter and reddit).

BTW this is the same guy that confirmed BF4 running over 720p on PS4 and the latest rumors says 1080p native.

I will be surprised if Xbone SP looks worst than PS4 MP



attaboy on 25 October 2013

Regardless of which version looks better, it's not the end all though.

We've seen Genesis games look better than Super Nes games some of the time, PS2 games look better than Gamecube games sometime and PS3 games look better than 360 games sometimes (I'm talking multi-plats, here). What will matter is which console has the best version more consistently. That won't be proven by just one game from one dev. It'll take time for the clear leader to be shown--if the clear leader is ever shown.



ethomaz on 25 October 2013
selnor1983 said:
Oh snap.

If the One starts do win graphics awards and have the better versions then all Ill say is told you so. The One is designed differently. Microsoft have said it. 3rd party devs from Capcom, Bethesda, ID Software have all said both systems are equalish. Somethings are better on one hardware and others on the other.

Like alot of devs have said including John Carmack. Building and developing games on console is no longer about raw speed to achieve the best visuals.

Well anyhow. Day 1 for Xbox One for me.

If the things turn out different you will admit the Xbone is weak?



Porcupine_I on 25 October 2013

well, he obviously already comfirmed the better version!

ONE is better!



“It appeared that there had even been demonstrations to thank Big Brother for raising the chocolate ration to twenty grams a week. And only yesterday, he reflected, it had been announced that the ration was to be reduced to twenty grams a week. Was it possible that they could swallow that, after only twenty-four hours? Yes, they swallowed it.”

- George Orwell, ‘1984’

Around the Network
Imaginedvl on 25 October 2013
Normando said:

Yah, surprisinly you only see it 2 ways and the 2 ways is negative for the Xbox One if we listen to you :)
Love how people are really trying hard to make it look bad for the Xbox One and/or making excuses already for the PS4 even without knowing exactly what the guy is talking about...

If the SP version of the Xbox One is better than the MP version of the PS4; care to explain where that 50% more powerfull is? Or you are going to pretend that the single player of the game must be 50% better (graphicaly) than the SP? 

You guys are not real lol You are so afraid whenever anything a bit negative (not even confirmed) may be posted about the PS4... Funny :)

What? Care to point out when I said the PS4 was 50% more powerful? I know others have said it. But I haven't and have made no suggestion to that being the case. 

Care to explain what would constitute one game looking "50%" better?

Care to point out another way that this could turn out?

Edit: if it does turn out that there is a 50% ish power gap in the hardware it's important to remember that graphics suffer from diminishing return (50% more in doesn't mean 50% more out) 

http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/167673-ps4-and-xbox-one-the-diminishing-returns-of-next-gen-console-graphics

lol, sorry if you are mad about that 50% more power but if you scroll up and take the time to read YOUR post; you seem to believe that the it will be impossible for the Xbox One SP to be at the same quality of the PS4 SP... So you know, maybe you do not believe it should be 50% better but at the end; you got my point.

You can stick on this 50% if you want instead of the real issue with your post; that's fine :) This guy is clearly implying that one version is better and it looks like (pure speculation at this point) that it is the Xbox One. So yah, keep going with all your reasoning arround the poor video quality, or SP vs MP (seriously lol; the guy just said he recorded SP on X1 and MP on PS4; I do not think he compared those 2 videos but the whole game); the possiblity that the Xbox One is just better (SP vs SP) or (MP vs MP) seem very probable right there...



Imaginedvl on 25 October 2013
pezus said:
Imaginedvl said:

lol, sorry if you are mad about that 50% more power but if you scroll up and take the time to read YOUR post; you seem to believe that the it will be impossible for the Xbox One SP to be at the same quality of the PS4 SP... So you know, maybe you do not believe it should be 50% better but at the end; you got my point.

You can stick on this 50% if you want instead of the real issue with your post; that's fine :) This guy is clearly implying that one version is better and it looks like (pure speculation at this point) that it is the Xbox One. So yah, keep going with all your reasoning arround the poor video quality, or SP vs MP; the possiblity that the Xbox One is just better (SP vs SP) or (MP vs MP) seem very probable right there...

Lol, I'd say it's quite the opposite, actually. Almost everything thus far points towards the PS4 version of many of the multiplats being better. But as you say, this is pure speculation until we get proper comparisons. SP vs. MP isn't it. Especially for a game with such a HUGE MP like BF.

Well you are talking rumors on the internet about 720p for the Xbox One?

But for this guy, I do not see what is pointing toward the PS4 behind better? You are right tho; not really pointing toward the Xbox One I must admit :)



ethomaz on 25 October 2013

Imaginedvl said:

Well you are talking rumors on the internet about 720p for the Xbox One?

But for this guy, I do not see what is pointing toward the PS4 behind better? You are right tho; not really pointing toward the Xbox One I must admit :)

He is the same guy?



Normando on 25 October 2013
Imaginedvl said:
Normando said:

Yah, surprisinly you only see it 2 ways and the 2 ways is negative for the Xbox One if we listen to you :)
Love how people are really trying hard to make it look bad for the Xbox One and/or making excuses already for the PS4 even without knowing exactly what the guy is talking about...

If the SP version of the Xbox One is better than the MP version of the PS4; care to explain where that 50% more powerfull is? Or you are going to pretend that the single player of the game must be 50% better (graphicaly) than the SP? 

You guys are not real lol You are so afraid whenever anything a bit negative (not even confirmed) may be posted about the PS4... Funny :)

What? Care to point out when I said the PS4 was 50% more powerful? I know others have said it. But I haven't and have made no suggestion to that being the case. 

Care to explain what would constitute one game looking "50%" better?

Care to point out another way that this could turn out?

Edit: if it does turn out that there is a 50% ish power gap in the hardware it's important to remember that graphics suffer from diminishing return (50% more in doesn't mean 50% more out) 

http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/167673-ps4-and-xbox-one-the-diminishing-returns-of-next-gen-console-graphics

lol, sorry if you are mad about that 50% more power but if you scroll up and take the time to read YOUR post; you seem to believe that the it will be impossible for the Xbox One SP to be at the same quality of the PS4 SP... So you know, maybe you do not believe it should be 50% better but at the end; you got my point.

You can stick on this 50% if you want instead of the real issue with your post; that's fine :) This guy is clearly implying that one version is better and it looks like (pure speculation at this point) that it is the Xbox One. So yah, keep going with all your reasoning arround the poor video quality, or SP vs MP (seriously lol; the guy just said he recorded SP on X1 and MP on PS4; I do not think he compared those 2 videos but the whole game); the possiblity that the Xbox One is just better (SP vs SP) or (MP vs MP) seem very probable right there...

Uhh? Are we talking about the same thing? You're the one who brought up the 50% more power thing...I never even said anything about the power difference until you brought it up.

I also never said anything about SP vs. SP or MP vs. MP. You're just trying to put words in my mouth. It's totally possible that the Xbox One version turns out better (but it isn't very likely). I was just pointing out that because it's a comparison between the Ones SP and the PS4s MP it doesn't put the Xbox in a position of strength. Maybe this will make it more clear.  3 things could happen with this comparison:

1: The PS4 version looks better = PS4 version is going to look better and probably alot better because it's MP looks better than the Ones SP.

2: They look the same = PS4 version is going to look better because it's MP looks as good as the Ones SP.

3: The One version looks better = This doesn't tell us anything because SP is supposed to look better than MP. So the One version could look better, or they could be the same, or the PS4 version could still look better.

All I'm saying, and all I've been saying since I first posted in this thread. Is that regardless of how this comparo goes, because the One version is operating in a mode that by default should make it look better. The best case scenario for the One is that the comparo is inconclusive.

Make sense now?



Imaginedvl on 25 October 2013
Normando said:
Imaginedvl said:
Normando said:

What? Care to point out when I said the PS4 was 50% more powerful? I know others have said it. But I haven't and have made no suggestion to that being the case. 

Care to explain what would constitute one game looking "50%" better?

Care to point out another way that this could turn out?

Edit: if it does turn out that there is a 50% ish power gap in the hardware it's important to remember that graphics suffer from diminishing return (50% more in doesn't mean 50% more out) 

http://www.extremetech.com/gaming/167673-ps4-and-xbox-one-the-diminishing-returns-of-next-gen-console-graphics

lol, sorry if you are mad about that 50% more power but if you scroll up and take the time to read YOUR post; you seem to believe that the it will be impossible for the Xbox One SP to be at the same quality of the PS4 SP... So you know, maybe you do not believe it should be 50% better but at the end; you got my point.

You can stick on this 50% if you want instead of the real issue with your post; that's fine :) This guy is clearly implying that one version is better and it looks like (pure speculation at this point) that it is the Xbox One. So yah, keep going with all your reasoning arround the poor video quality, or SP vs MP (seriously lol; the guy just said he recorded SP on X1 and MP on PS4; I do not think he compared those 2 videos but the whole game); the possiblity that the Xbox One is just better (SP vs SP) or (MP vs MP) seem very probable right there...

Uhh? Are we talking about the same thing? You're the one who brought up the 50% more power thing...I never even said anything about the power difference until you brought it up.

I also never said anything about SP vs. SP or MP vs. MP. You're just trying to put words in my mouth. It's totally possible that the Xbox One version turns out better (but it isn't very likely). I was just pointing out that because it's a comparison between the Ones SP and the PS4s MP it doesn't put the Xbox in a position of strength. Maybe this will make it more clear.  3 things could happen with this comparison:

1: The PS4 version looks better = PS4 version is going to look better and probably alot better because it's MP looks better than the Ones SP.

2: They look the same = PS4 version is going to look better because it's MP looks as good as the Ones SP.

3: The One version looks better = This doesn't tell us anything because SP is supposed to look better than MP. So the One version could look better, or they could be the same, or the PS4 version could still look better.

All I'm saying, and all I've been saying since I first posted in this thread. Is that regardless of how this comparo goes, because the One version is operating in a mode that by default should make it look better. The best case scenario for the One is that the comparo is inconclusive.

Make sense now?

Maybe we are saying the same thing after all...

Nothing from the OP is saying that he is comparing MP to SP. Actually; the guy certainly compared MP with MP and SP with SP; but JUST because he said that he also got a full recording of SP on X1 and MP on PS4; people are assuming that he is comparing X1 SP vs PS4 MP because they are afraid that the better looking version he is talking about is the Xbox One...

Now; yah like Pezus said; he may also be talking about the PS4; who knows... But if he is talking about the X1, my point is that he is certainly talking about SP-SP and MP-MP and not MP(PS4) vs SP(X1)...