By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - Pokemon XY VGChartz User Ratings! If You Played The Game Come and Rate It Here...

Welcome to The First Official VGChartz User Review Score Thread! Here I'll Come Up with 5 categories to rate from 1-10 (no decimals) You post what you give in each Category. I'll only take ratings from people who played the entire game. So if your a person who wants to come here and troll its not going to work cuz most people here kno who play pokemon XY! We have several threads to point it out!

So With out further a Dont lets begin! (Warning, if you troll by giving out low scores i will not count them unless you give a reasonable explanation)

Copy this and give out your own scores from 1-10! I'll do an average once we have at least 10 ratings!

1.⇒Graphics/Details Improvement?

2.⇒Gameplay/Mechanics?

3.⇒Story/Difficulty and Replay Value/Length of Game?

4.⇒Extra Feats/Multiplayer?

5.⇒Overall Pokemon Generation Compared To Others?

 

★Ratings out of __!

96 ~ Tbone51

90 ~ Lelouch_Vi_Brittania 

100 ~ BasilZero



Around the Network

↓↓↓Tbone51↓↓↓

1.⇒Graphics/Details Improvement? 10/10

2.⇒Gameplay/Mechanics? 9/10 (Love the gameplay but even with Mega Evolutions we got a few new pokemon!)

3.⇒Story/Difficulty and Replay Value/Length of Game? 8/10 (Story was cool, but the replay value and length of game is a 10!)

4.⇒Extra Feats/Multiplayer? 10/10 (Best nuff said)

5.⇒Overall Pokemon Generation Compared To Others? 10/10 (Best Generation Overall)

→→→→→Conclusion= 47/50 (96/100)



1.⇒Graphics/Details Improvement? (8/10)

Graphically the game is ok, they adopted a cell-shading style, even though the pokédex 3D and Mystery Dungeon already had lots of 3D models ready they had the work to make 718 only for this game, so I won't be saying they were lazy with the graphics. And a strange detail I noticed: Pikachu says "Pika Pika" but all the other mons still make the same sound!?!

2.⇒Gameplay/Mechanics? (9/10)

It plays totally like a pokémon game, I even felt strange when I first played the game, I was expecting something totally different, but the game felt familiar, just in 3D, probably thanks to the Cell-Shaded graphic that helped the mons feel like living sprites. It's in 3D, but it's still pokémon, if it's good or bad, the players decide. I thought it was good. '-'

3.⇒Story/Difficulty and Replay Value/Length of Game? (9/10)

The game couldn't beat the Black/White saga, storywise. But I think it's still better than the other games in terms of story. Still, I thought the game was quite easy, for the first time in a pokémon game, I beat the E4 in my first try! Hell, My vivillion soloed the champion! And about length, I took around 30 hours to complete.

4.⇒Extra Feats/Multiplayer? ( 9/10)

The multiplayer just isn't perfect because we can't have 6x6 random battles. And I still want to know if I can upload my battles on the PGL.

5.⇒Overall Pokemon Generation Compared To Others? (10/10)

Designwise this gen is really good.



 

 

 

At least let me get round to playing the frickin' game first!



brendude13 said:
At least let me get round to playing the frickin' game first!


"You just got the game now?" Lets laugh at brendude JK, well 95% got it day 1 sooooo..... Come back wen you beat it lol



Around the Network
tbone51 said:
brendude13 said:
At least let me get round to playing the frickin' game first!


"You just got the game now?" Lets laugh at brendude JK, well 95% got it day 1 sooooo..... Come back wen you beat it lol





n00b, getting the game 1 WHOLE WEEK later, I pity you



 

 

 

brendude13 said:
tbone51 said:
brendude13 said:
At least let me get round to playing the frickin' game first!


"You just got the game now?" Lets laugh at brendude JK, well 95% got it day 1 sooooo..... Come back wen you beat it lol



Dont worry and beside you'll be too busy having fun with XY



pezus said:
Isn't it a bit early to be rating it? o.O

Back in the day it took months for me to properly complete Pokemon Red and Gold


why? You dont need to properly complete XY to give it a score cuz if you did there wouldn't be one review in the world lol