By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - Mafia Round 58: Avatar The Last Airbender

Vetteman94 said:
benao87 said:

Benao-Katara (town healer)
Radish - Sokka Friendly Neighbour
Astro - Aang Jack-of-all-trades
Noctis - Iroh Motivator

Vetteman - Zuko Town Miller

Linkz - Zuki Town Roleblocker

Nacho- Appa Town Vanilla

Trashleg-???

Flavour backs my claim, and it also backs Radish, as he was the only one that voted for Vette, so he was the one that "tried to stop Aang" from lynching moreno.
I reckon that Astro is also town. And wiki says that motivator is usually town, so let's just say that noctis is also town.

That leaves us Vette, as town miller, Nacho, Town Vanilla, Linkz Town roleblocker, and Trashleg. From those four, there is 2~3 mafia.

My top two options for toDay would be Nacho and Linkz. Trashleg for good or for worse is going to be modkilled, so yeah, that would leave things between those two and Vette.

How does voting for me back up Radish's claim?  

And why should I just believe that Noctis is town?  

As for your who is left, I dont think there is enough confirmed to only have 4 left on there,  if you are going to take people at their word for their role claim,  why shouldn't you take the other peoples word for what they roleclaimed.  

Flavour:

supermario128 said:

 When Aang found out it was this merchant who had poisoned his beloved friend, King Bumi, he couldn't control himself. Sokka had to use all his strength to hold him back. It was decided he would die the same way he was killing everyone else. They forced him to keep eating and eating his cabbages. After numerous hours, and numerous cabbages this crazy merchant was no longer part of this world.

Moreno was lynched. He was the town vigilante.

Only he and yoshiya voted for you, the rest voted for Moreno. And Moreno was that cabbage merchant, thus I had a strong feeling that Radish was indeed Sokka, and why I wanted him to claim the last, because someone could've slipped a fake claim, with that one. And astro, him claiming the protagonist of the series would be a really bold fake claim, one probably way too bold.

Now, regarding noctis, wiki suggest that that role it's usually town, and linkz confirmed that he had two night actions on Night 2. I do wonder why he kept his last night action. Linkz could be lying, and supporting noctis fake claim. Under this scenario, nacho would be town, because Astro confirmed us that Linkz visited Nacho, and linkz role seems to be legit taking into account radish confirmed that he was blocked. Under this scenario mafia could be Linkz-noctis and maybe either you or trashleg.

If nacho is mafia, then I'd go with linkz being town (he woulnd't block a scum buddy), and that would make noctis very likely to be town too, as linkz wouldn't be lying about him having two actions Night 2, and motivator role being most likely town. Then mafia would be Nacho-trashleg and maybe you.

 

 

Radish, and astro are 100% town for me, I know that I'm town, and I know that flavour backs my claim. Trashleg will be modkill, and should only be taken into account for our chances for day 5 depending on her flip. That leaves us 2~3 mafia members (depending on trashleg's flip), between you, nacho, linkz, and noctis.

These scenarios are assuming stefl was town, and that there are 3 mafia members in the game (mario stated he needed 12 players for starting the game, then even if there were 13 at the beggining, 3 mafia would be the most likely scenario)

1. Trasleg is not mafia: There could be 3 mafia members between those 4, we mislynch we lose.

2. Trashleg is mafia: There are 2 mafia members between those 4, we can afford another mislynch.

If game keeps going after a mislynch, and trashleg is not mafia, then stefl was scum and we still need to find the other 2.

 

Nacho and linkz are most likely on different teams. If linkz is town, noctis is very likely to be town to.

Vote: linkz

If I'm wrong, nacho is mafia, but noctis would be verly likely be town. Vette could also be mafia (that's 2), and the other one could be trashleg (will be modkilled), or stefl. We will survive another round.



Around the Network
benao87 said:
Vetteman94 said:
benao87 said:

Benao-Katara (town healer)
Radish - Sokka Friendly Neighbour
Astro - Aang Jack-of-all-trades
Noctis - Iroh Motivator

Vetteman - Zuko Town Miller

Linkz - Zuki Town Roleblocker

Nacho- Appa Town Vanilla

Trashleg-???

Flavour backs my claim, and it also backs Radish, as he was the only one that voted for Vette, so he was the one that "tried to stop Aang" from lynching moreno.
I reckon that Astro is also town. And wiki says that motivator is usually town, so let's just say that noctis is also town.

That leaves us Vette, as town miller, Nacho, Town Vanilla, Linkz Town roleblocker, and Trashleg. From those four, there is 2~3 mafia.

My top two options for toDay would be Nacho and Linkz. Trashleg for good or for worse is going to be modkilled, so yeah, that would leave things between those two and Vette.

How does voting for me back up Radish's claim?  

And why should I just believe that Noctis is town?  

As for your who is left, I dont think there is enough confirmed to only have 4 left on there,  if you are going to take people at their word for their role claim,  why shouldn't you take the other peoples word for what they roleclaimed.  

Flavour:

supermario128 said:

 When Aang found out it was this merchant who had poisoned his beloved friend, King Bumi, he couldn't control himself. Sokka had to use all his strength to hold him back. It was decided he would die the same way he was killing everyone else. They forced him to keep eating and eating his cabbages. After numerous hours, and numerous cabbages this crazy merchant was no longer part of this world.

Moreno was lynched. He was the town vigilante.

Only he and yoshiya voted for you, the rest voted for Moreno. And Moreno was that cabbage merchant, thus I had a strong feeling that Radish was indeed Sokka, and why I wanted him to claim the last, because someone could've slipped a fake claim, with that one. And astro, him claiming the protagonist of the series would be a really bold fake claim, one probably way too bold.

Now, regarding noctis, wiki suggest that that role it's usually town, and linkz confirmed that he had two night actions on Night 2. I do wonder why he kept his last night action. Linkz could be lying, and supporting noctis fake claim. Under this scenario, nacho would be town, because Astro confirmed us that Linkz visited Nacho, and linkz role seems to be legit taking into account radish confirmed that he was blocked. Under this scenario mafia could be Linkz-noctis and maybe either you or trashleg.

If nacho is mafia, then I'd go with linkz being town (he woulnd't block a scum buddy), and that would make noctis very likely to be town too, as linkz wouldn't be lying about him having two actions Night 2, and motivator role being most likely town. Then mafia would be Nacho-trashleg and maybe you.

 

 

Radish, and astro are 100% town for me, I know that I'm town, and I know that flavour backs my claim. Trashleg will be modkill, and should only be taken into account for our chances for day 5 depending on her flip. That leaves us 2~3 mafia members (depending on trashleg's flip), between you, nacho, linkz, and noctis.

These scenarios are assuming stefl was town, and that there are 3 mafia members in the game (mario stated he needed 12 players for starting the game, then even if there were 13 at the beggining, 3 mafia would be the most likely scenario)

1. Trasleg is not mafia: There could be 3 mafia members between those 4, we mislynch we lose.

2. Trashleg is mafia: There are 2 mafia members between those 4, we can afford another mislynch.

If game keeps going after a mislynch, and trashleg is not mafia, then stefl was scum and we still need to find the other 2.

 

Nacho and linkz are most likely on different teams. If linkz is town, noctis is very likely to be town to.

Vote: linkz

If I'm wrong, nacho is mafia, but noctis would be verly likely be town. Vette could also be mafia (that's 2), and the other one could be trashleg (will be modkilled), or stefl. We will survive another round.

Alright



Vetteman94 said:

Alright


Who are you voting for?



benao87 said:
Vetteman94 said:

Alright


Who are you voting for?


No one,  I want more people on and posting before I cast my vote.   

There are some interesting scenarios being discussed and i would like to see others comment on the situation. 



Voting to lynch (It takes 5 votes):

Player L-4 L-3 L-2 L-1 Lynched!
Linkz
Nacho
 Benao  







 

Voting for time limit (It takes 3 votes):

L-2 L-1 In place!



--------------------------------------

Nacho: Linkz
Benao: Linkz




Nintendo still doomed?
Feel free to add me on 3DS or Switch! (PM me if you do ^-^)
Nintendo ID: Mako91                  3DS code: 4167-4543-6089

Around the Network

Vetteman94 said:

I don't like that you lied about your role,  to me it just seems like you waited for everyone to post their roles and then picked one that was likely to not show up from the ones that havent posted yet.  I think you were nervous of the attention you got and are now making up your role change.  


All I got from your second paragraph is that most roles fit the flavor and you don't buy Linkzmaz story about being a Twon Roleblocker and that he is a Mafia Roleblocker and that I agree with.  The rest is flavor stuff and I know nothing about that.  

As for your scenario there are a few holes I see.  First off who suggested that I was a Godfather or a possibility of one?  Being a Miller I would scan scum, being a Godfather I would scan town.  If I was Godfather I wouldnt have claimed anything day 1 as I would come up town from a cop scan and just coast to the end.  Claiming Miller I brought alot of attention to myself and a possibility of a cop scan with it.  if it came up innocent they would know I was lying.  Also if the beginning of the scenario you suggest that Mafia may have to kill me due to lack of choices in the game with your scenario which I would agree if it was all true. And why would you and I being lynched be able to garuntee a win for town?  With me being Town Miller how would me being dead help the town this late in the game?   Especially considering my role fits the flavor you are using for half your reasoning.  


Also there is no "r" in my name,  its just Vetteman

I didn't suggest you were a Godfather. I suggested trashleg was your godfather, you are Mai and I'm not quite sure what power you have.

With 6 alive and 4 of them being confirmed town, you and I would be the only ones unconfirmed and one of us would be guaranteed scum. Regardless of who was lynched first, we would still be able to lynch the other one and pull out a win.



Vetteman94 said:
benao87 said:
Vetteman94 said:

Alright


Who are you voting for?


No one,  I want more people on and posting before I cast my vote.   

There are some interesting scenarios being discussed and i would like to see others comment on the situation. 

You don't want to bus your buddy, I guess.



Vetteman94 said:
benao87 said:
Vetteman94 said:

Alright


Who are you voting for?


No one,  I want more people on and posting before I cast my vote.   

There are some interesting scenarios being discussed and i would like to see others comment on the situation. 

Ok, then how about discussing such scenarios. Would you like to add something?



Nachomamma8 said:
Vetteman94 said:
benao87 said:
Vetteman94 said:

Alright


Who are you voting for?


No one,  I want more people on and posting before I cast my vote.   

There are some interesting scenarios being discussed and i would like to see others comment on the situation. 

You don't want to bus your buddy, I guess.

There it is, you got me.........

Or Im waiting to see what everyone else thinks.  I have had suspicions of Linkz since his claims.   In fact I believe I was the first one to call him on his roleblocker claim as being town and not Mafia like it normally is.  Why does this day have to get over so quickly?  Why cant others comment on the situation, afraid they may say something? 



Well, I don't know if this is of any relevance but Moreno targeted Stefl.
So stefl's alignment is still isn't town.