LOL Having been a teenager and now raising one I can emphatically tell you teenagers in general DO IN FACT believe they know more than any adult. They have reasons for everything they do dumb or not. They are egocentric and feel as though they are invincible (those two are in any life cycle or human development psychology class).

So yes it is typical teenage behavior. And as one would expect in such extreme circumstances as the world in TLOU this would more than likely be more pronounced.

so much fail in a single post. i.. i just don't know how to respond

Man, I have missed your posts =)

So you believe there is nothing more to reality than what we perceive? So I guess you believe that everything just happen to make itself out of nothing, or you really haven't thought much about life. Please tell me, how did nothing create everything. Because nothing can do precisely nothing. And btw, science strongly supports the notion that the universe was created from nothing. Please enlighten me?

From a scientist's point of view: It's better to admit you don't know something and work at understanding it than to just assume whatever makes the most sense to you.  So yes the idea of something coming from nothing doesn't make a ton of sense based on our current logic and understanding, but rather than just assume that the answers from religion are correct I would rather wait for our understanding to improve than just assume we'll never understand it.  

I'm not going to enligten you because you can't argue with ignorance. Case closed.

Even though I liked Heavy Rain for the most part I totally agree with your statement about the begining of the game the plot makes no sense.

why should all people in such a world believe in god when they have zombie like monsters running around eating other humans?

if you believe in god you would also believe that god is a reason for that. not sure if many people would be still religious then.

in some countries we have already more people who don't believe in god as people who do, not to mention how many different religions and beliefs we have on this planet. so, if it is already like this nowadays, what do you expect with infected humans which look like broccoli?

and did you see the video of the woman who thought she is hiring a killer to kill her friend? it's not as if some woman don't have an evil character. did you see a video of a violent nanny and what they can do with babies? 

Nonsense this game is perfect I tell YOU!

He's not the only ignorant one, in this case.

OT: The only thing I can agree with, in your OP, is the fact that developers/directors/etc. seem to always make teenagers/younger people have a large understanding of what the world is or how it works or what is right and wrong. It's annoying and can become arrogant sounding at times. (This is coming from a teenager. Suprisingly.)

Still, most of your points seem odd. A teenager being disrespectful to her elders? Not odd at all. Someone questioning God if they never get a chance to really get out of an apocalypse? Not odd, sadly.