Kasz216 said:
Very few people ever watched Wrestling for the fake fighting... it was more for the rest of the drama. It's why action cartoons aren't just 100% fighting etc. It's the storytelling that pulls it all together (which has also sucked.)
|
I think MMA might have helped the decline by providing an alternative that is more attractive to some people when wrestling was already in the shitter, but I don't think it's simply a case of, "Who needs fake fighting when there's real fighting now?" The worst thing to happen to American wrestling is simply that Vince McMahon finally secured the monopoly he'd always wanted and was instantly (and may still be) of the opinion that, "Now WCW fans will have no choice but to watch our product." It's like if Xbox 360 had achieved PS2 levels of domination and Microsoft felt no pressure not to go through with all the Xbone policies. Of course, it's an incredibly stupid mindset as entertainment is probably the most fungible of commodities. People may like wrestling, but they can either watch it... or not.
The rise of Pride FC didn't seem to hurt Japanese wrestling at the time because the Japanese promotions were still capable of putting on a compelling product. NJPW had always dabbled in mixed matches and promoting professional wrestling as simply the strongest martial art in the world, anyway, so they were able to co-opt Pride's rise, and that of MMA in general, by having crossover matches between pro wrestlers and MMA guys.
In some ways this all just seems a very typical, cyclical thing. The '80s saw a massive boom. The '90s kind of lived off of that boom as a lot of guys had gotten into the business were starting to come into their own, and you had an explosion of stylistic diversity with a lot of promotions offering an incredible variety of styles. But those indies really may have just been the last gasp of the territories as things continued moving towards more and more centralization until you could really only make money in the WWF or WCW... and then just the WWF. You also had people pushing the envelope in terms of what the human body can sustain, and a lot of those guys are broken down or dead now. So maybe the '00s and '10s are just the natural bust after the boom.
By the time I quit watching, I'd noticed that while a lot of the best wrestlers had always just been huge guys or good athletes who had washed out of other sports and fallen ass backwards into a wrestling career, there were more and more kids turning up who weren't that physically impressive, had watched wrestling all of their lives and dreamed of becoming wrestlers, and very visibly couldn't believe their luck that they had finally "made it". It always gave me the uncomfortable feeling that I was watching fan fiction. This phenomenon seems to have reached its logical conclusion with The Miz.