By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Will robots ever deserve rights?

 

Answer the Damn Question!

Yes 32 41.03%
 
No 46 58.97%
 
Total:78
kowenicki said:
No.

Most humans don't deserve the rights they have, so robots never will.


I saw the thread title and came in to post exactly this

Damn you Kowen.....



Around the Network
Veracity said:


I think, therefore I am. This applies to animals as well. There is an intimate relationship between consciousness and mind. One does not exist without the other.


Sure, you know you have consciousness. But how do you know other humans and animals have consciousness? What proof do you have of this that cannot also be applied to a robot?



Jay520 said:
Veracity said:


I think, therefore I am. This applies to animals as well. There is an intimate relationship between consciousness and mind. One does not exist without the other.


Sure, you know you have consciousness. But how do you know other humans and animals have consciousness? What proof do you have of this that cannot also be applied to a robot?

Because every human, when presented with the question of "do you exist" responds in the same affirmative manner. An extension to animals would be their ability to avoid predators realizing "they" are and need to avoid threats. 

It is a byproduct of a brain. Trees are not conscious at the macro level.



If I can have sex with them I don't see why not.



Nintendo and PC gamer

They will be treated as personal property, nothing more.

I mean its taking us 2000+ years to get rid of racial and gender prejudice.......I think after that point were just gonna call it a day and forget the rights of robots and aliens :P



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

Around the Network

The key concept with artificial intelligence is self-awareness. Even before self-awareness is attained, a computer must have exhibited the ability to transcend its programing. Once the A.I. begins to grow and develop its own processes, to think its own thoughts, then it's on the path. When we can look at a computer system and say, "OK, none of this was programmed in," that's the point at which we really need to think about this.

Makes me want to read Neuromancer or watch Serial Experiments Lain again, or at least Ergo Proxy.



Veracity said:

Because every human, when presented with the question of "do you exist" responds in the same affirmative manner. An extension to animals would be their ability to avoid predators realizing "they" are and need to avoid threats. 

It is a byproduct of a brain. Trees are not conscious at the macro level.


So responding "yes" to the question "do you exist?" is proof of consciousness?

Computers can do that today.



kowenicki said:
Jay520 said:
kowenicki said:
No.

Most humans don't deserve the rights they have, so robots never will.


Fair enough. But do you think robots will ever get these rights under law, even if they don't deserve them?


Did you miss the first word of my post? 


You answered if robots would ever deserve rights. But that's not the question I asked you when I quoted you.



sales2099 said:
They will be treated as personal property, nothing more.


Many people believe that conscious beings cannot become owned.



kowenicki said:

No I didn't. I answered a firm "no" with a full stop. Them I just decided to elaborate by widening the discussion. 


Thread asked, "Will robots ever deserve rights?"

Then I asked you, "Will robots ever get these rights under law?"

Two different questions.