By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - motion controls, will they ever appeal to the "core" gamers?

 

will motion controls ever appeal to the core?

Yes 43 47.25%
 
No 44 48.35%
 
See results 4 4.40%
 
Total:91
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:

oniyide said:

motion+ got atrocious support, worst than move or kinect

Maybe in quantity, but not in quality.


when only about four of those games are actually worth a damn and its been on the market since 09 that is nothing to be proud of.

Neither are Kinect and Move though. I'd still contend that neither device had a game in the league of Skyward Sword.

Killzone, Portal 2, Bioshock Infinite, Resistance, Infamous 2, thats of the top of my head, Really? The Move is getting support still and motion + hasnt for a while. Thats a fact. Skyward Sword is overrated probably the worst of the 3d Zeldas, i would place Portal 2 and Bioshock above it easily Kinect doesnt really do 'core' gaming so you got me there.

I haven't had  a chance to play Bioshock Infinite yet, (I really want to, I adore the first one) but I'd say Skyward Sword is easily better than Killzone 3, Resistance 3, Infamous 2, or Portal 2.


your opinion is your opinion but that doesnt change the fact that it got pretty bad support and continues to get bad support, one game that game out the year before last doesnt change that, not when the other two are still gettting support



Around the Network
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:

oniyide said:

motion+ got atrocious support, worst than move or kinect

Maybe in quantity, but not in quality.


when only about four of those games are actually worth a damn and its been on the market since 09 that is nothing to be proud of.

Neither are Kinect and Move though. I'd still contend that neither device had a game in the league of Skyward Sword.

Killzone, Portal 2, Bioshock Infinite, Resistance, Infamous 2, thats of the top of my head, Really? The Move is getting support still and motion + hasnt for a while. Thats a fact. Skyward Sword is overrated probably the worst of the 3d Zeldas, i would place Portal 2 and Bioshock above it easily Kinect doesnt really do 'core' gaming so you got me there.

I haven't had  a chance to play Bioshock Infinite yet, (I really want to, I adore the first one) but I'd say Skyward Sword is easily better than Killzone 3, Resistance 3, Infamous 2, or Portal 2.


your opinion is your opinion but that doesnt change the fact that it got pretty bad support and continues to get bad support, one game that game out the year before last doesnt change that, not when the other two are still gettting support


is there any info or source that states how many people play those kinda games with Move? im interested in knowing how popular it is with core centric games.



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

zorg1000 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:

oniyide said:

motion+ got atrocious support, worst than move or kinect

Maybe in quantity, but not in quality.


when only about four of those games are actually worth a damn and its been on the market since 09 that is nothing to be proud of.

Neither are Kinect and Move though. I'd still contend that neither device had a game in the league of Skyward Sword.

Killzone, Portal 2, Bioshock Infinite, Resistance, Infamous 2, thats of the top of my head, Really? The Move is getting support still and motion + hasnt for a while. Thats a fact. Skyward Sword is overrated probably the worst of the 3d Zeldas, i would place Portal 2 and Bioshock above it easily Kinect doesnt really do 'core' gaming so you got me there.

I haven't had  a chance to play Bioshock Infinite yet, (I really want to, I adore the first one) but I'd say Skyward Sword is easily better than Killzone 3, Resistance 3, Infamous 2, or Portal 2.


your opinion is your opinion but that doesnt change the fact that it got pretty bad support and continues to get bad support, one game that game out the year before last doesnt change that, not when the other two are still gettting support


is there any info or source that states how many people play those kinda games with Move? im interested in knowing how popular it is with core centric games.

No clue to be honest. But IMHO the important thing is that they have the OPTION to use Move



oniyide said:
zorg1000 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:

oniyide said:

motion+ got atrocious support, worst than move or kinect

Maybe in quantity, but not in quality.


when only about four of those games are actually worth a damn and its been on the market since 09 that is nothing to be proud of.

Neither are Kinect and Move though. I'd still contend that neither device had a game in the league of Skyward Sword.

Killzone, Portal 2, Bioshock Infinite, Resistance, Infamous 2, thats of the top of my head, Really? The Move is getting support still and motion + hasnt for a while. Thats a fact. Skyward Sword is overrated probably the worst of the 3d Zeldas, i would place Portal 2 and Bioshock above it easily Kinect doesnt really do 'core' gaming so you got me there.

I haven't had  a chance to play Bioshock Infinite yet, (I really want to, I adore the first one) but I'd say Skyward Sword is easily better than Killzone 3, Resistance 3, Infamous 2, or Portal 2.


your opinion is your opinion but that doesnt change the fact that it got pretty bad support and continues to get bad support, one game that game out the year before last doesnt change that, not when the other two are still gettting support


is there any info or source that states how many people play those kinda games with Move? im interested in knowing how popular it is with core centric games.

No clue to be honest. But IMHO the important thing is that they have the OPTION to use Move

i agree, i wasnt trying to discredit core games on Move or anything like that, just genuinly curious.

But the only way i can see the big mainstream/core gamers flocking to motion controls is by making it the only option. I think it just comes down to people being happy with dual analog controls and dont see any need to change them.



When the herd loses its way, the shepard must kill the bull that leads them astray.

oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:
oniyide said:
curl-6 said:

oniyide said:

motion+ got atrocious support, worst than move or kinect

Maybe in quantity, but not in quality.


when only about four of those games are actually worth a damn and its been on the market since 09 that is nothing to be proud of.

Neither are Kinect and Move though. I'd still contend that neither device had a game in the league of Skyward Sword.

Killzone, Portal 2, Bioshock Infinite, Resistance, Infamous 2, thats of the top of my head, Really? The Move is getting support still and motion + hasnt for a while. Thats a fact. Skyward Sword is overrated probably the worst of the 3d Zeldas, i would place Portal 2 and Bioshock above it easily Kinect doesnt really do 'core' gaming so you got me there.

I haven't had  a chance to play Bioshock Infinite yet, (I really want to, I adore the first one) but I'd say Skyward Sword is easily better than Killzone 3, Resistance 3, Infamous 2, or Portal 2.


your opinion is your opinion but that doesnt change the fact that it got pretty bad support and continues to get bad support, one game that game out the year before last doesnt change that, not when the other two are still gettting support

One game better than anything on the other two though. Like  said, quality over quantity.



Around the Network
Angelus said:
bananaking21 said:

usually, Kinect and PS move games are ignored by the "core gamers". Wii is said to be a console that doesnt attract the core as well because of its motion controlls. but the question is, will all that ever change? will there be a time where the regular and frequent gamers like our selfs be genuinely interested in motion control gaming?

also lets not act like moton controls do appeal to the core, MS and sony us the kinect and move to appeal to a wider audince, basically the "casuals". so lets not make the thread about whether or not the core audince already like motion controls.

Uhm....they do actually.

I enjoy playing some motion controlled games, as do many of my friends who are core gamers. They can be a lot of fun when you're playing with a group of people. This notion that core gamers can't possibly like motion controls is just absurd 

they do? then tell me what games that are coming out now that support motion controlls? look at the list of games with motion controls and tell me if really, that list would attract all the core audince. 

im not saying people dont or shouldnt enjoy motion controls. but it would be ludicrous if someone suggests that they appeal to a huge part of the core audince. why are people taking offense in that is beyond me



echoesfromthepast said:
I'm a core gamer and my favourite controller is the Wiimote.
Deal with it.


why would i have a problem with that?

but my point is, you are just an individual, not an entire market



J_Allard said:
A console with motion controls won this generation and will sell over 100,000,000 units.

/thread


yes, a console that used the blurmarket strategy, which in the Wii's case it didnt try to attract the "core" gamers but it expanded the market by offering something that appeals to people who did not game. the Wii's sales success and drop of sales at the end of its life shows that the market that it appealed too isnt the same as the one as the ps360



For competitive stuff no. In general, mostly No.



bananaking21 said:
Angelus said:
bananaking21 said:

usually, Kinect and PS move games are ignored by the "core gamers". Wii is said to be a console that doesnt attract the core as well because of its motion controlls. but the question is, will all that ever change? will there be a time where the regular and frequent gamers like our selfs be genuinely interested in motion control gaming?

also lets not act like moton controls do appeal to the core, MS and sony us the kinect and move to appeal to a wider audince, basically the "casuals". so lets not make the thread about whether or not the core audince already like motion controls.

Uhm....they do actually.

I enjoy playing some motion controlled games, as do many of my friends who are core gamers. They can be a lot of fun when you're playing with a group of people. This notion that core gamers can't possibly like motion controls is just absurd 

they do? then tell me what games that are coming out now that support motion controlls? look at the list of games with motion controls and tell me if really, that list would attract all the core audince. 

im not saying people dont or shouldnt enjoy motion controls. but it would be ludicrous if someone suggests that they appeal to a huge part of the core audince. why are people taking offense in that is beyond me


All of the core audience? lol

No game ever made attracts all of the core audience. Your OP implied that no core gamer could possibly find motion controls appealing, which is simply not true.