By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - I got my first forum ban ever ... from NeoGAF of all places ... and I don't get why

wfz said:
I find it interesting that saying "gay" in a derogatory fashion got you banned, but people outright saying they want to put their penis in her, cum inside her, etc., didn't receive any warnings for rudeness or PC.



Right, comment that sticks out the most from what i read was "I would put my penis inside her and leave it in because i would be afraid it wouldn't get back there"



Around the Network
braiks said:

You used "gay" as a derogatory word, stop playing dumb. One is not suddenly gay if he does not like feminine women. Maybe he likes the "supermodel" type. Less feminine features and less curves.

On another note, I like feminine women...like Emma Watson.

No, I didn't.  Stop trying to tell me what my intentions were.  Dude called a woman less shapely than the "supermodel" type too curvey.  He didn't like feminine women.  He started talking about androgynous FF characters.  Why am I being lambasted for asking if he was saying that he's gay??????



Dodece said:
You deserved to get banned, because even if you weren't calling the poster in question Gay. You indeed implied that there was something unsavory about being Gay. Whether it was in jest or not. You were feeding into a very negative very persistent stereotype. It just isn't appropriate to refer to anything as being Gay anymore. It really says more about the demographic then the object in question.

Especially if the object in question is in anyway out of the norm. It is basically a veiled attack that denigrates a entire group of people. Through the implication that they are not normal. Which is actually not how Gay people want to be viewed by society. They want you to recognize that their lifestyle is equally valid, and entirely normal. Implying otherwise is quite insulting.

That is how I see it. You probably shouldn't refer to anything as being Gay anymore. If for no other reason then it is insensitive to our LGBT brothers and sisters.

... wait ... are you saying that we shouldn't refer to anything as gay anymore, even it is literally gay (as in LGBT)???!!!

What's more disturbing than anything is how people can take the most literal question and spin it as an insult.  You're about to make me whip out Cos again ...



I get the ban. I do. Though honestly, I don't even understand the image. Memes are supposed to be funny. That wasn't very funny?

I guess if you weigh the humor against the actual text... it can be perceived more to be leaning towards an insult than actually trying to make a clever humorous jab. Because to me, if you were trying to be funny... it fell very flat... it more easily just reads as a verbal insult, like you are using 'gay' as a snide/snarky remark, not engaging in any witty reparte... Not saying your intentions are so, but if you forget what makes that funny to you, then maybe you can see how that context affects the weight of the post itself?


If you don't, don't worry about it I guess. Just be careful next time you use that word in that way lol...

I'm kinda weirded out by this... to me, gay originally meant 'really happy', and then somewhere it became homosexual (or always was?)... but to me, it also means 'lame' or 'not cool', without either of those contexts. I have no idea if you meant homosexual gay or 'lame gay' and it's sometimes too hard to tell, but with the context of the quote, it's easier to think you were talking very directly about homosexuality... and not in a joking manner... but anyway

Example: If someone says "What is this gay?" or "That is gay"... I think 'lame', nothing at all about sexual preference... maybe because that's how I became accustomed to it being used as a casual slang term. Though, I'm sure some mean to use it to insult gay people and put them under an umbrella label that says 'lame' (i.e. not fitting in) that you theoretically don't want to be put under at the same time... so I can understand the desire to stop that conflicting/oppressive message from being injected there.

It's just so weird how that word can have so many meanings. We need just need to stop reusing words and come up with some new ones...



badgenome said:

Without having seen the post that got you banned, I'm pretty confident in saying that you were banned because GAF is a wannabe country club with the worst moderation in the history of everything.

Edit: Found the post. Yeah, I'm not surprised that got you banned. GAF is the probably the single most PC place I've seen on the 'net.

This. NeoGAF moderations are a joke. You have to be very careful on what you say, especially if you're a junior member there.

Even the Gamespot forums in the System Wars section & the systemwars.com forums lets people say anything that they want.



Around the Network

Lame ban. Post was hilarious.



Wow you posted an image that had the word gay on it and were not permabanned. Congrats.

NeoGAF is a great forum to read up on gaming news but I rarely, rarely ever post in OT because there is no telling what kind of depressed mod/backseat mod you're going to offend with any type of post. They also go way overboard with the LGBT or whatever brigade.



Two reasons for the possible ban one you post a giant GIF with Bill Cosby in it. Two using gay in that manner in not really appropriate.



cmeese47 said:
Two reasons for the possible ban one you post a giant GIF with Bill Cosby in it. Two using gay in that manner in not really appropriate.

In WHAT manner???



if you bring up the word "gay" without clarifying you don't mean it in an insulting manner, but in this case just to say "into men", then that's usually a 50/50 ban chance, depending on the mod