I didn't recall any confusion regarding quicktopics on seth's part and I didn't find any such post when looking through the thread again. Maybe you are mixing this up with linkz's troll post in response to hatmoza?

Paranoia is part of the game, because virtually every situation can be interpreted or twisted to mean two very different things. seth could be nervous town who simply isn't sure what to do (being afraid of drawing unwarranted suspicion on himself) or he could be scum who pretends to be lost, because it's easy for a newbie to get by with that line of posting, at least for a while. If scum is allowed to Day-talk in their quicktopic (this rule isn't set in stone and up to the host to decide), then seth could be easily coached into saying these things.

Personally, my Day 1 reads are terrible, so I don't read too much into little things. I need more than a handful of posts to judge people properly, that's why I tend to encourage everyone to play the game and why I despise lurking. Also, in seth's case, there's this unwritten rule that we don't give newbies a hard time on Day 1 and we would only lynch them, if they made one hell of a slip. This doesn't mean that newbies should see Day 1 as a free pass though, because low or bad activity on Day 1 will come back to haunt them eventually, regardless of their alignment.

1. This is my first mafie game ever and my first mafia game on VGC

2. Scum in general benefits from a rushed lynch I would think, anyhow, it is probably not good scum strategy to draw early attention as trigger happy, so that counts against you being scum

3. Sure, you're not the only one whos said the same things. Yet, early in on a potential lynch bandwagon is not promising

5. Yes, I am a new player, everyone knows it, and it is showing in my game. It's not a secret, but you used the fact to weaken my reasoning which is a suspicious move. My argument is my argument regardless of my experience, it's either weak or solid on it's own. Opening with something like "That's a noob if I ever saw one" is a blatant attempt to make your claims carry more weight by appealing to your own superior experience. To me it's a pretty strong scum tell.

Anyway, I'll be competely honest and say that I don't feel the least bit bad about the attempt at linking me and Haz and color us scum. It is however one more attempt to point the finger, another distraction if you will, perhaps a good thing for scum that as many as possible get the shadows of suspicion cast upon them?

I'll also be completely honest and admit that I am not any less supicious of you.

SuperMario seems like scum to me but I think I'm getting a misread on him.

Be more confident with your opinions. To say something like this is very suspicious.

Im not going back to look for it now but you said to one of the new players "good now can you day talk?" so yes nen did.