At this point I think metacritic should just take out user scores because they are never accurate and just a bunch of exagerating fans. Not to mention lots of them doesn't even play the games. Anyways take a look.
91 Metacritic - 3.4 Userscore
http://www.metacritic.com/game/pc/simcity
Recent freakouts in metacritic has been Diablo III and Devil May Cry.
Diablo III is still the best FPS ever XP