By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Vote: Top 5 New IP's of the generation

007BondAgent on 25 January 2013

1. Uncharted
2. Assassins Creed
3. La Noire
4. Dark Souls
5. Red dead redemption



Around the Network
Jaywood2010 on 25 January 2013
bananaking21 said:
1-Uncharted
2-To The Moon
3-Heavy Rain
4- Assassin's Creed
5- LittleBigPlanet

and i have to disagree with you jaywood i would say uncharted2 was way more influential than any gears game. i didnt put gears in my list because i didnt play it


What has Uncharted brought besides cinematics?  Even then Gears was already cinimatic but not on the same level as uncharted




       

ice on 25 January 2013

Only two people mentioned VC???? :/

1)Minecraft
2)Valkyria Chronicles
3)Borderlands
4)Littlebigplanet
5)Assassins Creed



bananaking21 on 25 January 2013
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
1-Uncharted
2-To The Moon
3-Heavy Rain
4- Assassin's Creed
5- LittleBigPlanet

and i have to disagree with you jaywood i would say uncharted2 was way more influential than any gears game. i didnt put gears in my list because i didnt play it


What has Uncharted brought besides cinematics?  Even then Gears was already cinimatic but not on the same level as uncharted

i was already starting reading some articles to make a thread about this (uncharted 2's influence and not comparing it too gears) so i dont have remember/know everything it did. but it did change alot

Animation (facial and body animations)

technology

level desgin (this is related alot to the technology aspect)

Cinematics, yes i understand that gears had cinematics. a lot of games has them too before (god of war for example) but uncharted2/3 just brought them to a hole new level

charecter development 

story telling 

graphics

im not downplaying gears, it certainly had a big splash and infleunce, but i see uncharted did effect the indusrty more. even long succesful series like tomb raider and even resident evil had been influenced by uncharted



Jaywood2010 on 25 January 2013
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
1-Uncharted
2-To The Moon
3-Heavy Rain
4- Assassin's Creed
5- LittleBigPlanet

and i have to disagree with you jaywood i would say uncharted2 was way more influential than any gears game. i didnt put gears in my list because i didnt play it


What has Uncharted brought besides cinematics?  Even then Gears was already cinimatic but not on the same level as uncharted

i was already starting reading some articles to make a thread about this (uncharted 2's influence and not comparing it too gears) so i dont have remember/know everything it did. but it did change alot

Animation (facial and body animations)

technology

level desgin (this is related alot to the technology aspect)

Cinematics, yes i understand that gears had cinematics. a lot of games has them too before (god of war for example) but uncharted2/3 just brought them to a hole new level

charecter development 

story telling 

graphics

im not downplaying gears, it certainly had a big splash and infleunce, but i see uncharted did effect the indusrty more. even long succesful series like tomb raider and even resident evil had been influenced by uncharted


Story telling has been here for years and years and that is nothing new, same thing with graphics.  Level design also was not influential what so ever? In fact everything you said was not transferred to other games?  I have never disagreed with you in this way and it surprises me to see you come up with a poor list like this.





       

Around the Network
bananaking21 on 25 January 2013
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
1-Uncharted
2-To The Moon
3-Heavy Rain
4- Assassin's Creed
5- LittleBigPlanet

and i have to disagree with you jaywood i would say uncharted2 was way more influential than any gears game. i didnt put gears in my list because i didnt play it


What has Uncharted brought besides cinematics?  Even then Gears was already cinimatic but not on the same level as uncharted

i was already starting reading some articles to make a thread about this (uncharted 2's influence and not comparing it too gears) so i dont have remember/know everything it did. but it did change alot

Animation (facial and body animations)

technology

level desgin (this is related alot to the technology aspect)

Cinematics, yes i understand that gears had cinematics. a lot of games has them too before (god of war for example) but uncharted2/3 just brought them to a hole new level

charecter development 

story telling 

graphics

im not downplaying gears, it certainly had a big splash and infleunce, but i see uncharted did effect the indusrty more. even long succesful series like tomb raider and even resident evil had been influenced by uncharted


Story telling has been here for years and years and that is nothing new, same thing with graphics.  Level design also was not influential what so ever? In fact everything you said was not transferred to other games?  I have never disagreed with you in this way and it surprises me to see you come up with a poor list like this.

i didnt say it came up with something new in those points, but i ment it changed/did them in a way that really wanst done before in that level of quality, i can explain my points but i didnt want to derail your thread (and possibaly start a flame war) 

in



Jaywood2010 on 25 January 2013
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
1-Uncharted
2-To The Moon
3-Heavy Rain
4- Assassin's Creed
5- LittleBigPlanet

and i have to disagree with you jaywood i would say uncharted2 was way more influential than any gears game. i didnt put gears in my list because i didnt play it


What has Uncharted brought besides cinematics?  Even then Gears was already cinimatic but not on the same level as uncharted

i was already starting reading some articles to make a thread about this (uncharted 2's influence and not comparing it too gears) so i dont have remember/know everything it did. but it did change alot

Animation (facial and body animations)

technology

level desgin (this is related alot to the technology aspect)

Cinematics, yes i understand that gears had cinematics. a lot of games has them too before (god of war for example) but uncharted2/3 just brought them to a hole new level

charecter development 

story telling 

graphics

im not downplaying gears, it certainly had a big splash and infleunce, but i see uncharted did effect the indusrty more. even long succesful series like tomb raider and even resident evil had been influenced by uncharted


Story telling has been here for years and years and that is nothing new, same thing with graphics.  Level design also was not influential what so ever? In fact everything you said was not transferred to other games?  I have never disagreed with you in this way and it surprises me to see you come up with a poor list like this.

i didnt say it came up with something new in those points, but i ment it changed/did them in a way that really wanst done before in that level of quality, i can explain my points but i didnt want to derail your thread (and possibaly start a flame war) 

in


Let me put it this way.

Gears already had story development

It already had the graphics

It alread had animations

It  had cinimatics

And it had story telling.

Uncharted didnt really do anything new.  It just perfected the cinimatic experience which is a series of development over time.  Gears literally changed TPS games and brought Hoarde mode which is now seen on many games.  As i said before without gears many games would not be the same as they are now and that even includes Uncharted.  

EDIT: And don't worry about a flamewar.  Consider this a debate rather than an argument.  




       

Jaywood2010 on 25 January 2013
CGI-Quality said:
^ ^ I don't want to continue to ruin what should be a simple thread, and I know one of these isn't a new IP, but the two more likely candidates for "most influential games of this gen" are Wii Sports and Call of Duty.

Gears of War was very influential, more so than any other 3rd person franchise, but not on that level, and of late, Uncharted has also had a major impact on how people craft their titles.

Just my take.


As I said before dont worry about ruining the thread.  This just helps it stay up longer and brings in a good conversation at the same time.

I would also consider call of duty and Wii sports influential.  As i said before Call of Duty has changed online gaming.  Wii Sports i simply just didnt think about it.




       

bananaking21 on 25 January 2013
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:


Let me put it this way.

Gears already had story development

It already had the graphics

It alread had animations

It  had cinimatics

And it had story telling.

Uncharted didnt really do anything new.  It just perfected the cinimatic experience which is a series of development over time.  Gears literally changed TPS games and brought Hoarde mode which is now seen on many games.  As i said before without gears many games would not be the same as they are now and that even includes Uncharted.  

i have to go in a few so ill either write on your wall or reply here and explain my points. and @ bolded, im not disagreeing with any of that. but uncharted did bring a not of new stuff, i just dont have the time to explain now. if u dont want me to derail your thread with this, just write on my wall. when i can ill reply with my point. just dont think im talking out of my ass lol



Jaywood2010 on 25 January 2013
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:
JayWood2010 said:
bananaking21 said:


Let me put it this way.

Gears already had story development

It already had the graphics

It alread had animations

It  had cinimatics

And it had story telling.

Uncharted didnt really do anything new.  It just perfected the cinimatic experience which is a series of development over time.  Gears literally changed TPS games and brought Hoarde mode which is now seen on many games.  As i said before without gears many games would not be the same as they are now and that even includes Uncharted.  

i have to go in a few so ill either write on your wall or reply here and explain my points. and @ bolded, im not disagreeing with any of that. but uncharted did bring a not of new stuff, i just dont have the time to explain now. if u dont want me to derail your thread with this, just write on my wall. when i can ill reply with my point. just dont think im talking out of my ass lol

I love uncharted and it definitely is an amazing game, i just dont see how it brought anything new to the table.  I just think it ranks up there with the best of the best.  Anyways I will wait til you get back and you can tell me later why you think what you think.  Just send me a PM sometime.  Later bro