Who called this a Smash Bros killer?

That's like calling Dissidia not a new IP. makes no sense

And LOL At Sly vs Drake conversation....

This was basically the entire reason for GT review score, it was crazy, every other sentence had Smash Brother's in it. I don't even think Prototype and Infamous had comparisons of this level and they released on one of the same platforms and at the same time!

Overall, I'm happy with the reviews so far, it seems like quite a good game, so it's definitely being bought for Christmas :D

I don´t know anything about Dissidia

FF Dissidia..the game where characters from the Final Fantasy duke it out. Your argument would make sense if this was an HD collection or something but this is just a cross over mascot brawler..with its own game mechanics, story etc. It's a fact that this is a new IP

Gamespot posted a hilarious video review. I'd like to see who can spot all the funny quotes in it.

Sitting at 77 on meta critic

So it's basically a good game not great but good.

That doesn't mean the game is bad and I hope people don't it as such.

Smb seems to hold it's place.

Honestly, these are good reviews when you consider the inevitable comparisons to brawl.... some people negative because they see it as a rip off, others negative because they don't think it rips it off enough.

That's like saying Kingdom Hearts wasn't a new IP because it had characters from Disney movies and Final Fantasy games.

I think people forget that there's a real world outside of these forums, so whatever is said on here is how much hype there actually is.