By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - PlayStation All Stars is not a Smash Bros. clone

Tagged games:

 

How much did you read?

The whole linked article 20 25.97%
 
The excerpt 6 7.79%
 
The bold parts 4 5.19%
 
Just the poll 46 59.74%
 
Total:76
Lafiel said:
phenom08 said:

Are you a native english speaker? If not thanks for making it obvious lol. We aren't texting so you can spell things out lol. I'm not fighting a fight, that implies we both could win. He lost the second he asked how it was a clone of Smash and so did you. Also if anyones the partisan its you for quoting me in the first place. I surely didn't start this "debate" with you.

Haha, yea you just baited very well by calling a perfectly fine game a "very bad game", well done. The beta is surprisingly fun and btw I'm playing it right as we speak :). I'm not sure how any of the SSB online parts worked (I only played it at friend's homes, although I do own a GC), but judging from the beta PASBR is doing fine in that regard. Have a good day, sir.

I'm not baiting, I was just stating an opinion. Which is probably true about it. Good that you are enjoying it, I thought it was crap, played it, and found out it was crap, no need to be mad at me.



Around the Network
JoeTheBro said:
phenom08 said:
Lafiel said:
phenom08 said:
Lafiel said:
phenom08 said:

Its one of the most shameful clones the world has ever seen. Its what you get if Ninty did everything wrong with smash and put these characters in it. PSABR is a very bad game.

a clone is sth. that is completely the same - does that mean you think SSB is a "very bad game" ?

What is sth, and read my post again.

an abbreviation of "something" I thought you would realize that as a native english speaker *shrugs*

btw go, fight the good fight little partisan *eats popcorn*

Are you a native english speaker? If not thanks for making it obvious lol. We aren't texting so you can spell things out lol. I'm not fighting a fight, that implies we both could win. He lost the second he asked how it was a clone of Smash and so did you. Also if anyones the partisan its you for quoting me in the first place. I surely didn't start this "debate" with you.

Not picking sides (even though my sig and avater do that for me) but you think it is a knock off, not a clone. Use that word from now on to avoid any confussion.

Why? Clone is fine because that is what it is. Sony can't release literally the same game as Smash so of course it was altered lol. So no, I'm sticking to clone, although rip off or knock off is fine as well.



phenom08 said:

Are you a native english speaker? If not thanks for making it obvious lol. We aren't texting so you can spell things out lol. I'm not fighting a fight, that implies we both could win. He lost the second he asked how it was a clone of Smash and so did you. Also if anyones the partisan its you for quoting me in the first place. I surely didn't start this "debate" with you.

Phenom says: "We aren't texting so you can spell things out"

His very next word: "lol"

Interesting indeed



It kind of is.

Brawl is not a genre, so making a brawl type fighter, while clearly being inspired by Smash Bros. (making a very similar game, doing away with aspects that you don't like) is essentially making a clone.

I hear that this game is so much like Smash Bros, even the button layout and attack configuration is the same.



What is with all the hate? Don't read GamrReview Articles. Contact me to ADD games to the Database
Vote for the March Most Wanted / February Results

Jay520 said:
phenom08 said:

Are you a native english speaker? If not thanks for making it obvious lol. We aren't texting so you can spell things out lol. I'm not fighting a fight, that implies we both could win. He lost the second he asked how it was a clone of Smash and so did you. Also if anyones the partisan its you for quoting me in the first place. I surely didn't start this "debate" with you.

Phenom says: "We aren't texting so you can spell things out"

His very next word: "lol"

Interesting indeed

You got me Jay lol, you couldn't wait to find that. Nice try though, I told him that because not everyone has seen all these different abbreivations while lol is pretty common, well known and widely used. "sth" not so much.



Around the Network
phenom08 said:
JoeTheBro said:
phenom08 said:
Lafiel said:
phenom08 said:
Lafiel said:
phenom08 said:

Its one of the most shameful clones the world has ever seen. Its what you get if Ninty did everything wrong with smash and put these characters in it. PSABR is a very bad game.

a clone is sth. that is completely the same - does that mean you think SSB is a "very bad game" ?

What is sth, and read my post again.

an abbreviation of "something" I thought you would realize that as a native english speaker *shrugs*

btw go, fight the good fight little partisan *eats popcorn*

Are you a native english speaker? If not thanks for making it obvious lol. We aren't texting so you can spell things out lol. I'm not fighting a fight, that implies we both could win. He lost the second he asked how it was a clone of Smash and so did you. Also if anyones the partisan its you for quoting me in the first place. I surely didn't start this "debate" with you.

Not picking sides (even though my sig and avater do that for me) but you think it is a knock off, not a clone. Use that word from now on to avoid any confussion.

Why? Clone is fine because that is what it is. Sony can't release literally the same game as Smash so of course it was altered lol. So no, I'm sticking to clone, although rip off or knock off is fine as well.


Thank you for making it obvious you aren't in any mood for an actual discussion. Either stop posting in my thread or start using logic and common sense. Look up "knock off" if you have to.



JoeTheBro said:


Thank you for making it obvious you aren't in any mood for an actual discussion. Either stop posting in my thread or start using logic and common sense. Look up "knock off" if you have to.

Excuse me lol. Have you even read what your own thread title says? It makes a statement and I disagree with it. I am using logic, you are saying its not a clone because they aren't exactly the same. I'm saying well yea it can't be the same or Sony would get sued lol. It still has plenty of similarities enough for you to even mention it not being a Smash clone. No need to be upset with me. It is what it is and that's a clone.



Yep it's a rip off, not a clone. It's a great game, but it was heavily inspired in smash. Some people argue that just because the method of scoring points it's different its a "completely different game", but it's not. Almost everything else is a carbon copy of smash, with little differences (like having stages being a mash up of 2 franchises instead of of just one for example; or having Sony characters instead of Nintendo ones) 

Even the copycat company Gameloft who makes clones of famous franchises inject some "unique" ideas to their games, like their ones characters or stories. 



Mr Khan said:

If you have a problem with a post, report it. As i've said before, we're always watching.

Sometimes double standards are applied. Is there someplace to report that?



i found the demo at eb expo and the beta version really boring . That my honest opinion.

Things i didn't like

Combo's don't feel satisfying. Without any damage meter, pulling off a combo doesn't feel rewarding. Sure you build up meter, but you never truly feel you are on top of the opponent.

From just playing the beta i can see some balancing issues. A lot of people see kratos as overpowered and i kinda agree. Not sure how the final game will turn out, but having super as a only methods will kill the game, it just seems unbalanced to me.

Overall i found the game clunky and slow paced. i'll wait and see how the final products turn out before deciding to purchase it or not.



Bet with ninjablade:

Ninjablade wins if the next 5 multiplat on the wii u are inferior to the 360 version.

I win if one of the 5 mulitplats are on par or superior on the Wii U.