People can already do that. In this very thread.

An inactive thread.  DOnt you think that people might want to see if others agree with them or not?  Example, if i want to say i disagree with goatseye''s ban in XBO Nation i should be able to do that.  There is no harm in that.  IM not causing a riot, i just find it to be a dumb ban.  I shouldnt have a mod come in and warn more or that.  Im simply seeing if others agree with me or not.  

honestly I just don't see how this:

"I didn't "give the game away" because I didn't know he was an alt. I commented on his wall because of his ban explanation, which said he was an alt. I was surprised he was an alt, honestly, because, as I said, he was very different."

breaks the "At any rate you know the drill by now. Don't discuss it here, or you'll be banned. PM Smeags or Axum with complaints or voice them in the official thread. "

as the thing not to discuss was the ban/moderation as pezus was clarifying that he didn't know the guy was an alt which cone previously claimed/implied. (while related topics are not 1 in the same) the other part is just him asking for clarification on what cone was talking about when he said "If anything it could make it worse. If you've got issues just say rather than trying to hide it and pretend it'll all blow over, because let me assure you it will not." that had nothing to do with moderation / rules at all.

Seems pretty active to me right now.

It's pretty simple really: 

- You want to be able to voice your disagreement with certain bans
- This thread not only allows you to do this but since it's centralized there's a good chance your issue will be addressed by a mod who will explain the situation or even reverse the ban if you make a strong case for why the ban is not warranted.

It's active now but only with a handful of users posting. Why doesn't this show up in hot topics? A lot of people will never even know about this thread since they don't go into the forum index. 

I'll repeat mods@vgchartz does not work but axum has posted his mail somewhere

I don't completely agree with you here jay, as it can derail a thread greatly. I mean I definately think people should be able to ask about what happened when a user gets banned in one of the community threads, but talking about whether it was right or wrong should take place here. The problem is when it gets to far people just complain about rules or moderations in a community thread when that isn't the place for that. Then on the other side someone gets banned unjustly for asking a simple question or a simple comment that has no polarity in regards to the mods.

oh i'd say pezus deserved it for having an attitude that resembles sneaky jabbing below the belt in boxing

I agree with you.

THis is my last comment in here but im pretty sure its because me, and like 2 other people is making it active.  Id hardly call that all of vgc.