@NinPie: Very good argument.

I've been trying to answer everything people have asked me, and if I missed something, please, tell me. Your case is very, very weak.

Hmm... Are Prof and HappyD the siblings?

moreno claims MUGEN is the obvious most likely sibling for Happy, therefore, it's nothing too remarkable for him to point that fact out, and if MUGEN denies it (goes the theory) then Happy's claim is disproven and we can all lynch him with a clear conscience. 

Problem is, that's all bullshit.  But his post was most certainly part of a coherent conversation, contrary to your allegation. 

Yup, you're clearly not town.

morenoingrato said: @NinPie: Very good argument. I've been trying to answer everything people have asked me, and if I missed something, please, tell me. Your case is very, very weak.

I also went earlier into this thread, you were a little iffy back there too. I'll keep my HoS on you, you're suspicious but not to an extent that warrants a vote.

He is ruining the obfuscation of my sibling, but you aren't town either, so you wouldn't know. 

Or, you're playing dumb.

Your accusations of people "not being town" or "you're a scum" are really blown out of proportion.

Here's my list of who looks suspicious or not:

Probably town: Final-Fan (seems normal), Hatmoza (seems like normal/used to the game), spurgeonryan (seems normal), M.U.G.E.N (doesn't post so often, but isn't suspicious to me), RolStoppable (seems normal), TruckOSaurus (seems normal), Wonktonodi (quite sure about him), nen-suer (seems normal)

Undecided: Linkzmax (didn't notice him too much), stefl1504 (sure likes to vote and unvote a lot),  NintendoPie (not as active as expected), V the p00 (prof) (not sure...),  pezus (tending to think town, but not sure), supermario128 (not sure...), Linkzmax (not sure...), BasilZero (he basically left, so I assume he has no powerful role to say the least)

Probably/maybe scum: happydolphin (argues a lot; sibling story could be true or made up and there's really no way to tell), Radishhead (not really sure, could probably put him to undecided, too), morenoingrato (asks people to reveal pm info, which is forbidden by rules... but I'm very close to put him in my undecided category)

Most of it is gut feeling.

I might have missed some fine nuances (if there are any) of the discussion, because I practically raced through several hundred posts.

@spurge. Oh, don't worry, the veterans will get it.

I really don't believe your sibling claim just like Moreno btw &i really don't like what the town has to do to verify you claim.

To prove your telling the truth we have to let the doc protect you and the cop scan you (and with that Mafia gets an easy night kill tonight).

Then the cop must come forward and reveal his result, now the doc must protect him (and you) until he dies giving the mafia even more room in night actions.

Seems to me you made the best of bad situation and sibling claim is just a smart cover.

Sibling worth 2 townies and can be a brilliant claim for scum because its a role that gives you importance while avoiding the major roles that are

most likely present in the game.

Knowing that i still cant lynch you specially when most of the town dont want too.

I dont apporve of Moreno's methods, but i share his beliefs..