And even if he is, it's not like I'm giving Mafia something they already didn't know.

still you asking for a confirmation which is too scummy.

Also HD may have lied about that part to protect his sibling.

He maybe a noob, but i don't think he's stupid.

Is this supposed to be a reply to someone/something? You've been just posting these comments lately that aren't connected to a conversation it seems.

@SonyTart: I was telling it to nen-suer.

@Nen:
Could be, but so far, he has not been the brightest dolphin of the sea. And we only lose one candidate if he is lying to protect the sibling. Not a huge risk.

^But then why would you want to know if I'm not lying. That's the scummy part about it.

I want to know if you are lying or not.
If you are, you are protecting your sibling, or, we are back at Mafia.

This would only make sense in a context of mafia scanning the playfield to lynch the sibling and get both out. I really don't see it making any sense in the context of townies. Townies would never ever want the other sibling to be found. Come on.

To explain... the reason why that is a very mafia thing to do is this.

The doctor, thank the lord for that role, can only defend one townie at night. If you expose my sibling (as you're doing), that's 2 townfolk dead in one night, no matter what the doctor does.

You simply can't defend a legitimate motivation of trying to discover my sibling.

If M.U.G.E.N is indeed not the sibling, I won't look for him further, because there's even a higher chance you are scum.

I'm trying to prove he doesn't exist, and if MUG isn't your sibling, there's a very high chance he is just a fabrication.