thought the game was ok too in between a 8 and 9, possible spoiler alert below
i liked it more than AT b/c you play as drake alone more and was a little more challenging especially if you used the default aim settings. length was the same as previous entries 11hrs on hard, set pieces in AT felt like there were more, you got to take down 3 helis, a tank, and the chase/getaway sequences found in 1 and 2 felt more action pack then the horse ride found in 3
one thing i would want from future uncharted games would be more gun play like in the first and in the coop adventures found in 2 and 3, theres very little replay value in the 2nd and 3rd campaigns the gunplay found in the first with destructible cover and in the coop makes the player think and requires skill to complete. then again there could very well not be anymore UC games the ending in 3 made me feel that drake and elena are together(married) yuck, and elena doesnt not want drake to go fortune hunting since AT as well ans ND has not continued past created series so i dont know how it will continue
in no way or form do i feel that UC2 and 3 campaigns are the best ever or even this gen, not even close b/c for me there story's are kinda childish saturday morning cartoon type, and the actual game play has been toned down since DF and compared to other games, other TPS action games that i consider to be the best in the last 10 or so yrs with great gameplay and storys would be RE4, MGS1, 3 and 4, gears of war, maxpayne