@silver-tiger

Username - is nice and easy to remember and does not have any numbers in it.
Avatar - is good and goes well with your username, I don't like cats though. :P
Signature - ok I guess, atleast most of the games your hyped for I like as well. :)

You don't like cats?

@thePS3News
Avatar: 7/10 (It's a nice art, not too much to comment)
Sig: 7/10 (Hot asian gifs, not very creative and could be hotter but it's good)
Username: 6/10 (Easy to remember, but it's nothing special)

Total: 20/30

Username - 5/10 (Bunch of letters and numbers...bleh )
Avatar - 8/10 (Not sure who it is but I like it)
Sig - 10/10 (Extremely well put together and it's entirely awesome)

Total - 23/30

yo_john117 , thank you mate. My username is very bad but I didn't really think it would be important. My profile pic is from Fight Club, it's my favourite film. I suggest you to watch it.

Ratings:
Username: 5/10 (Not creative and not outstanding, just okay)
Sig: 9/10 (While I don't like FF, GOTM is a nice idea and your sigs are always great)
Avatar: 9/10 (Your avatar is awesome even though I dislike Halo)

Total: 23/30

Since my post is the last and I want to bump this thread, I shall rate myself.
Username: 6/10 (Really bad, it lacks creativity, smoothness etc but I've grow accustomed to it)
Sig: 10/10 (3 of my favourites TV Series ever, how could I possibly not like it?)
Avatar: 10/10 (My favourite film, again how could I possibly not like it?)

Total: 26/30

@PBBN43

Username: 3/10 *tut tut tut*
Avy: 10/10 Awesome film, awesome avatar
Sig: 8/10 was gonna be 10, -2 for monk

21/30

Username: 7/10
Avy: 10/10
Sig: 5/10 I'm not a Sony guy.

22/30

Andrespetmonkey:

Name: 8/10: easy to remember, simple and still good.
Avy:10/10: that monkey is just pure gold. And the "sup" is the icing of the cake :D
Sig:9/10: The Last of Us pic, quote of the team, and Naughty Dog logo, Awesomeness. I'm just missing a slight personal note for 10/10.

Overall: 27/30.

Username - 8/10 (pretty good)
Avatar - 7/10 (cats are cool)
Sig - 5/10 (just a boring words sig)

Total - 20/30