By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - Was MS Wrong When They Claimed The #1 Spot For HW Sales WW?

 

Which Option Do You Think Is More Accurate?

The PS3/360 Is Over/Undertracked In EU. 135 23.48%
 
Ballmer Was Including A Few Jan Shipments. 67 11.65%
 
MS Stuffed The Channels. 246 42.78%
 
IT'S 2012! WE'RE ALL GOING TO DIE! 123 21.39%
 
Total:571
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
ZaneWane said:
why is that xbox selling most console in 2011 is making people mad

Because it didn't. People saying Microsoft 'sold' more & moving the goal posts from sold to shipped is what is annoying ps3 fans.

Fixed. 

Seems the only people who do care are PS3 loyal. Nintendo fans dont care. 360 fans dont mind going by shipped. The only camp that is sensitive seems to have a PS3 bias. 

Personally this all stems from PS3 being last place. PS1/PS2 was on top and now PS3 is last and struggling to take 2nd. The fans are used to being #1 so whenever theres real facts that prove just how far the brand has fallen....they fight and spin and complain until they are convinced the PS3 ir performing like how the PS2 did. 

This might be out there, but I feel its the root of all this sensitivity. I can assure you the 360 camp doesn't mind this one bit. 

That's why i constantly see massive MS cheerleaders like you in nearly every single 360 vs ps3 2011 sales thread kicking up a fuss, acting in denial and only going by the numbers that suit the 360 best, pot calling kettle black.

It's as simple as this, this is a website that deals in ACTUAL SOLD TO CONSUMER NUMBERS NOT SHIPPED. Earlier in the year Microsoft claimed they would sell the most to consumers NOT SHIP THE MOST TO RETAILERS. Microsoft lost & because they lost now we have a situation where 360 fans constantly post and try to shift focus away from Microsoft losing their bet by bragging about profits and shipment numbers (whilst also being in denial that Microsoft overshipped).

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

Around the Network
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:

The magic of spin, even in utter defeat. Classic PS3 fan spin: if you cant argue it....ignore it lol. Ignore how MS just outperformed Sony on every level this year. 

Best part is, you can't prove that bolded statement. Its all spin and personal hopes and dreams lol. 

So until u CAN prove it, MS won. 

Since PS3 fans are saying that MS overshipped oct-dec with NO REAL PROOF. Let me say the same thing. I am announcing here and now that Sony overshipped PS3s in oct-dec as well. I have no proof of this, but that isnt stopping PS3 gamers from saying that about MS :)

No i HAVE already proved that Microsoft overshipped in the January-March 2011 quarter, just look back a few pages, it's there in black and white. I don't even need to wait for the next shipment data which will show even more overshipping in October-December by Microsoft as well. Keep trying.

You cant prove that MS overshipped in Oct-Dec. Its just your own personal spin. I could say the same thing about Sony.......

Nevermind that shipped is the official criteria of one corporation > another. This bickering about sold through is meaningless since it means nothing to MS and Sony. Keep trying  to spin. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:

The magic of spin, even in utter defeat. Classic PS3 fan spin: if you cant argue it....ignore it lol. Ignore how MS just outperformed Sony on every level this year. 

Best part is, you can't prove that bolded statement. Its all spin and personal hopes and dreams lol. 

So until u CAN prove it, MS won. 

Since PS3 fans are saying that MS overshipped oct-dec with NO REAL PROOF. Let me say the same thing. I am announcing here and now that Sony overshipped PS3s in oct-dec as well. I have no proof of this, but that isnt stopping PS3 gamers from saying that about MS :)

No i HAVE already proved that Microsoft overshipped in the January-March 2011 quarter, just look back a few pages, it's there in black and white. I don't even need to wait for the next shipment data which will show even more overshipping in October-December by Microsoft as well. Keep trying.

 

It seems that my post on the Nokia Lumia 800 got ignored. Nokia announced in their report that they shipped/sold over 1 million Windows Phone devices in Europe. The phone is doing extremely well.  Carriers across the continent were giving away free 360's as part of Nokia's and Microsoft's partnership and I'm convinced those real 360's getting into peoples hands did not get tracked by vgchartz.

Carriers in South Africa are doing the same thing. And carriers around the world will be doing the same thing when Nokia expands it's WP's across the globe. There is no doubt in my mind that the 360 outsold the PS3. Both shipped and sold thru.



sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
ZaneWane said:
why is that xbox selling most console in 2011 is making people mad

Because it didn't. People saying Microsoft 'sold' more & moving the goal posts from sold to shipped is what is annoying ps3 fans.

Fixed. 

Seems the only people who do care are PS3 loyal. Nintendo fans dont care. 360 fans dont mind going by shipped. The only camp that is sensitive seems to have a PS3 bias. 

Personally this all stems from PS3 being last place. PS1/PS2 was on top and now PS3 is last and struggling to take 2nd. The fans are used to being #1 so whenever theres real facts that prove just how far the brand has fallen....they fight and spin and complain until they are convinced the PS3 ir performing like how the PS2 did. 

This might be out there, but I feel its the root of all this sensitivity. I can assure you the 360 camp doesn't mind this one bit. 

That's why i constantly see massive MS cheerleaders like you in nearly every single 360 vs ps3 2011 sales thread kicking up a fuss, acting in denial and only going by the numbers that suit the 360 best, pot calling kettle black.

It's as simple as this, this is a website that deals in ACTUAL SOLD TO CONSUMER NUMBERS NOT SHIPPED. Earlier in the year Microsoft claimed they would sell the most to consumers NOT SHIP THE MOST TO RETAILERS. Microsoft lost & because they lost now we have a situation where 360 fans constantly post and try to shift focus away from Microsoft losing their bet by bragging about profits and shipment numbers (whilst also being in denial that Microsoft overshipped).

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 

The numbers on Vgchartz front page and in their weekly sales data is SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA NOT SHIPPED.

I have already proved that Microsoft overshipped in January-March 2011 a few pages ago, go back and read it, it's a fact. That's different from the up coming January-March 2012 data which we are yet to receive, you've got confused between the two and don't know what you are talking about.

Thanks again for your opinion that shipments and profits are better than actual sales to consumers on a website which is about sold to consumer data. I can tell already what kind of poster you are but you've picked the wrong guy to try and debate with because plain and simple you're wrong.



cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 

The numbers on Vgchartz front page and in their weekly sales data is SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA NOT SHIPPED.

I have already proved that Microsoft overshipped in January-March 2011 a few pages ago, go back and read it, it's a fact. That's different from the up coming January-March 2012 data which we are yet to receive, you've got confused between the two and don't know what you are talking about.

Thanks again for your opinion that shipments and profits are better than actual sales to consumers on a website which is about sold to consumer data. I can tell already what kind of poster you are but you've picked the wrong guy to try and debate with because plain and simple you're wrong.

Ya so u proved jan-mar 2011 but oct-dec over shipping is pure speculation on your part so id cut it out until the april results come in. 

Corporations criteria for victory > some guys on a forum. 

Jus saying



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

Around the Network
MaulerX said:
cookingyourmama said:

No i HAVE already proved that Microsoft overshipped in the January-March 2011 quarter, just look back a few pages, it's there in black and white. I don't even need to wait for the next shipment data which will show even more overshipping in October-December by Microsoft as well. Keep trying.

 

It seems that my post on the Nokia Lumia 800 got ignored. Nokia announced in their report that they shipped/sold over 1 million Windows Phone devices in Europe. The phone is doing extremely well.  Carriers across the continent were giving away free 360's as part of Nokia's and Microsoft's partnership and I'm convinced those real 360's getting into peoples hands did not get tracked by vgchartz.

Carriers in South Africa are doing the same thing. And carriers around the world will be doing the same thing when Nokia expands it's WP's across the globe. There is no doubt in my mind that the 360 outsold the PS3. Both shipped and sold thru.

It's not just Vgchartz numbers tho, it's GFK's and Nintendo's global tracking as well & they all show the 360 isn't selling miracle amounts in Europe. And yet again if some how their numbers are wrong then that would mean that for two quarters in a row Microsoft sold significantly more than they shipped which obviously is impossible. Those consoles you've mentioned have already been counted.



sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
ZaneWane said:
why is that xbox selling most console in 2011 is making people mad

Because it didn't. People saying Microsoft 'sold' more & moving the goal posts from sold to shipped is what is annoying ps3 fans.

Fixed. 

Seems the only people who do care are PS3 loyal. Nintendo fans dont care. 360 fans dont mind going by shipped. The only camp that is sensitive seems to have a PS3 bias. 

Personally this all stems from PS3 being last place. PS1/PS2 was on top and now PS3 is last and struggling to take 2nd. The fans are used to being #1 so whenever theres real facts that prove just how far the brand has fallen....they fight and spin and complain until they are convinced the PS3 ir performing like how the PS2 did. 

This might be out there, but I feel its the root of all this sensitivity. I can assure you the 360 camp doesn't mind this one bit. 

That's why i constantly see massive MS cheerleaders like you in nearly every single 360 vs ps3 2011 sales thread kicking up a fuss, acting in denial and only going by the numbers that suit the 360 best, pot calling kettle black.

It's as simple as this, this is a website that deals in ACTUAL SOLD TO CONSUMER NUMBERS NOT SHIPPED. Earlier in the year Microsoft claimed they would sell the most to consumers NOT SHIP THE MOST TO RETAILERS. Microsoft lost & because they lost now we have a situation where 360 fans constantly post and try to shift focus away from Microsoft losing their bet by bragging about profits and shipment numbers (whilst also being in denial that Microsoft overshipped).

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 

The numbers on Vgchartz front page and in their weekly sales data is SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA NOT SHIPPED.

I have already proved that Microsoft overshipped in January-March 2011 a few pages ago, go back and read it, it's a fact. That's different from the up coming January-March 2012 data which we are yet to receive, you've got confused between the two and don't know what you are talking about.

Thanks again for your opinion that shipments and profits are better than actual sales to consumers on a website which is about sold to consumer data. I can tell already what kind of poster you are but you've picked the wrong guy to try and debate with because plain and simple you're wrong.

Ya so u proved jan-mar 2011 but oct-dec over shipping is pure speculation on your part so id cut it out until the april results come in. 

Corporations criteria for victory > some guys on a forum. 

Jus saying

All independent sales data for Oct-Dec 2011 shows that Microsoft overshipped, we will know for 100% sure when the next shipment data comes in but pretending it isn't likely is incredibly naive. When companies constantly under or overship, using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless. Not only is this website about SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA but this thread is specifically about sold to consumer totals not shipped.



cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
ZaneWane said:
why is that xbox selling most console in 2011 is making people mad

Because it didn't. People saying Microsoft 'sold' more & moving the goal posts from sold to shipped is what is annoying ps3 fans.

Fixed. 

Seems the only people who do care are PS3 loyal. Nintendo fans dont care. 360 fans dont mind going by shipped. The only camp that is sensitive seems to have a PS3 bias. 

Personally this all stems from PS3 being last place. PS1/PS2 was on top and now PS3 is last and struggling to take 2nd. The fans are used to being #1 so whenever theres real facts that prove just how far the brand has fallen....they fight and spin and complain until they are convinced the PS3 ir performing like how the PS2 did. 

This might be out there, but I feel its the root of all this sensitivity. I can assure you the 360 camp doesn't mind this one bit. 

That's why i constantly see massive MS cheerleaders like you in nearly every single 360 vs ps3 2011 sales thread kicking up a fuss, acting in denial and only going by the numbers that suit the 360 best, pot calling kettle black.

It's as simple as this, this is a website that deals in ACTUAL SOLD TO CONSUMER NUMBERS NOT SHIPPED. Earlier in the year Microsoft claimed they would sell the most to consumers NOT SHIP THE MOST TO RETAILERS. Microsoft lost & because they lost now we have a situation where 360 fans constantly post and try to shift focus away from Microsoft losing their bet by bragging about profits and shipment numbers (whilst also being in denial that Microsoft overshipped).

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 

The numbers on Vgchartz front page and in their weekly sales data is SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA NOT SHIPPED.

I have already proved that Microsoft overshipped in January-March 2011 a few pages ago, go back and read it, it's a fact. That's different from the up coming January-March 2012 data which we are yet to receive, you've got confused between the two and don't know what you are talking about.

Thanks again for your opinion that shipments and profits are better than actual sales to consumers on a website which is about sold to consumer data. I can tell already what kind of poster you are but you've picked the wrong guy to try and debate with because plain and simple you're wrong.

Ya so u proved jan-mar 2011 but oct-dec over shipping is pure speculation on your part so id cut it out until the april results come in. 

 

Jus saying

All independent sales data for Oct-Dec 2011 shows that Microsoft overshipped, we will know for 100% sure when the next shipment data comes in but pretending it isn't likely is incredible naive. When companies constantly under or overship, using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless. Not only is this website about SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA but this thread is specifically about sold to consumer totals not shipped.

Thanks for defining Vgchartz and what the closedminded boundries of this thread are. 

"using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless". Oh contrair they wouldnt have been able to ship as much if actual sales couldnt keep up. But again its how corporations beat one another. 

 In the real world, Corporations criteria for victory > some guys on a forum. 

So, by all official counts. MS won 2011. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles. 

 

sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
ZaneWane said:
why is that xbox selling most console in 2011 is making people mad

Because it didn't. People saying Microsoft 'sold' more & moving the goal posts from sold to shipped is what is annoying ps3 fans.

Fixed. 

Seems the only people who do care are PS3 loyal. Nintendo fans dont care. 360 fans dont mind going by shipped. The only camp that is sensitive seems to have a PS3 bias. 

Personally this all stems from PS3 being last place. PS1/PS2 was on top and now PS3 is last and struggling to take 2nd. The fans are used to being #1 so whenever theres real facts that prove just how far the brand has fallen....they fight and spin and complain until they are convinced the PS3 ir performing like how the PS2 did. 

This might be out there, but I feel its the root of all this sensitivity. I can assure you the 360 camp doesn't mind this one bit. 

That's why i constantly see massive MS cheerleaders like you in nearly every single 360 vs ps3 2011 sales thread kicking up a fuss, acting in denial and only going by the numbers that suit the 360 best, pot calling kettle black.

It's as simple as this, this is a website that deals in ACTUAL SOLD TO CONSUMER NUMBERS NOT SHIPPED. Earlier in the year Microsoft claimed they would sell the most to consumers NOT SHIP THE MOST TO RETAILERS. Microsoft lost & because they lost now we have a situation where 360 fans constantly post and try to shift focus away from Microsoft losing their bet by bragging about profits and shipment numbers (whilst also being in denial that Microsoft overshipped).

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 

The numbers on Vgchartz front page and in their weekly sales data is SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA NOT SHIPPED.

I have already proved that Microsoft overshipped in January-March 2011 a few pages ago, go back and read it, it's a fact. That's different from the up coming January-March 2012 data which we are yet to receive, you've got confused between the two and don't know what you are talking about.

Thanks again for your opinion that shipments and profits are better than actual sales to consumers on a website which is about sold to consumer data. I can tell already what kind of poster you are but you've picked the wrong guy to try and debate with because plain and simple you're wrong.

Ya so u proved jan-mar 2011 but oct-dec over shipping is pure speculation on your part so id cut it out until the april results come in. 

 

Jus saying

All independent sales data for Oct-Dec 2011 shows that Microsoft overshipped, we will know for 100% sure when the next shipment data comes in but pretending it isn't likely is incredible naive. When companies constantly under or overship, using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless. Not only is this website about SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA but this thread is specifically about sold to consumer totals not shipped.

Thanks for defining Vgchartz and what the closedminded boundries of this thread are. 

"using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless". Oh contrair they wouldnt have been able to ship as much if actual sales couldnt keep up. But again its how corporations beat one another. 

 In the real world, Corporations criteria for victory > some guys on a forum. 

So, by all official counts. MS won 2011. 

I've already proved that they undershipped in Oct-Dec 2010 so in Jan-March 2011 they had to overship to make up for it. That's nothing to do with how much consumers were actually buying in Jan-March 2011.

Thanks again for your OPINION about corporations & shipped data on a website about sold to consumer data. Sony sold more whilst Microsoft shipped more, get over it.



cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
sales2099 said:
cookingyourmama said:
ZaneWane said:
why is that xbox selling most console in 2011 is making people mad

Because it didn't. People saying Microsoft 'sold' more & moving the goal posts from sold to shipped is what is annoying ps3 fans.

Fixed. 

Seems the only people who do care are PS3 loyal. Nintendo fans dont care. 360 fans dont mind going by shipped. The only camp that is sensitive seems to have a PS3 bias. 

Personally this all stems from PS3 being last place. PS1/PS2 was on top and now PS3 is last and struggling to take 2nd. The fans are used to being #1 so whenever theres real facts that prove just how far the brand has fallen....they fight and spin and complain until they are convinced the PS3 ir performing like how the PS2 did. 

This might be out there, but I feel its the root of all this sensitivity. I can assure you the 360 camp doesn't mind this one bit. 

That's why i constantly see massive MS cheerleaders like you in nearly every single 360 vs ps3 2011 sales thread kicking up a fuss, acting in denial and only going by the numbers that suit the 360 best, pot calling kettle black.

It's as simple as this, this is a website that deals in ACTUAL SOLD TO CONSUMER NUMBERS NOT SHIPPED. Earlier in the year Microsoft claimed they would sell the most to consumers NOT SHIP THE MOST TO RETAILERS. Microsoft lost & because they lost now we have a situation where 360 fans constantly post and try to shift focus away from Microsoft losing their bet by bragging about profits and shipment numbers (whilst also being in denial that Microsoft overshipped).

Im sorry but VG chartz does shipped articles all the time......

And you have NO proof of MS over shipping in Oct-Dec. Just personal propaganda to convince yourself. 

You dont get it...profits and shipment numbers is THE OFFICIAL criteria of how one corporation > another. So MS possibly lost their sold though bet....they still won on all official accounts, which is shipped and profits. 

The numbers on Vgchartz front page and in their weekly sales data is SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA NOT SHIPPED.

I have already proved that Microsoft overshipped in January-March 2011 a few pages ago, go back and read it, it's a fact. That's different from the up coming January-March 2012 data which we are yet to receive, you've got confused between the two and don't know what you are talking about.

Thanks again for your opinion that shipments and profits are better than actual sales to consumers on a website which is about sold to consumer data. I can tell already what kind of poster you are but you've picked the wrong guy to try and debate with because plain and simple you're wrong.

Ya so u proved jan-mar 2011 but oct-dec over shipping is pure speculation on your part so id cut it out until the april results come in. 

 

Jus saying

All independent sales data for Oct-Dec 2011 shows that Microsoft overshipped, we will know for 100% sure when the next shipment data comes in but pretending it isn't likely is incredible naive. When companies constantly under or overship, using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless. Not only is this website about SOLD TO CONSUMER DATA but this thread is specifically about sold to consumer totals not shipped.

Thanks for defining Vgchartz and what the closedminded boundries of this thread are. 

"using shipped data for a years worth of sales becomes pretty worthless". Oh contrair they wouldnt have been able to ship as much if actual sales couldnt keep up. But again its how corporations beat one another. 

 In the real world, Corporations criteria for victory > some guys on a forum. 

So, by all official counts. MS won 2011. 

I've already proved that they undershipped in Oct-Dec 2010 so in Jan-March 2011 they had to overship to make up for it. That's nothing to do with how much consumers were actually buying in Jan-March 2011.

Thanks again for you OPINION about corporations & shipped data on a website about sold to consumer data. Sony sold more whilst Microsoft shipped more, get over it.

"Sony sold more whilst Microsoft shipped more, get over it"

I totally get that. But it seems the argument now is which one should be the true measure of victory.

Im just saying that MS and SOny dont give a crap on sold through: they use shipped as their criteria for victory. 

Again....corporations criteria > Ours. Thanks for your OPINION but you really cant argue against MS beating Sony when BOTH measure shipped as criteria. 



Xbox: Best hardware, Game Pass best value, best BC, more 1st party genres and multiplayer titles.