By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Kinect vs PS Move vs Wii Motion Plus

gameonbro on 29 December 2011
dsage01 said:
gameonbro said:
kinect is #1 for me. why game developers are slow to the table when hacktivist show you street fighter 4, bulletstorm, dead island, star wars force unleashed 2, and even skyrim FUS RO DAH! The sad part is they look better than most kinect games by majors.

Those hacks also proove that with a simple scheme you can make kinect optional games.

Like it or not kinect is a blast with kin. Kinect parties are hella fun that will leave your sides hurting from laughing. Also kinect is the new family member you get to talk to lol...

its not that kinect isnt capable of hardcore the questions are do you want to play them if a developer actually makes one. sega tried with rise of nightmare.

the reason i put kinect #1 is for the mere fact if microsoft add a controller its the perfect package. full body tracking with precision shooting with actual throwing, ducking, reloading etc... oh my. which points out another sony failure. it wouldve been better if they came out with a new eye with the release of move than later.

I was going to give the other 2 a toss up but then i thought about it. we are judging motion + on what its doing for wii. what will it do for the wii u should be the question. with the wii u cam you have move.

As my 4 move controllers sit in a draw waiting for EA to stop being p*SS**s and put out fight night for 2 with 4 actual controllers I realize that might never happen. The developers will always sell move short because most people only have one controller. Now grand slam tennis 2 is all move


So I understand your viewpoint and why Kinect is your number one. But I don't get your number 2 and number 3 at all. If you can elaborate more on those points it can be nice because for WM+ your saying "what can it do for the Wii U" while we have we're just judjing on the controller not the system. For PS Move you want Fight Night to work with 4 controllers. 

i have fight thats why i bought the 4 controllers.  dont really like it.  i just want to float like a butterfly sting like a bee lol...

we are talking about the controller not the games.  so thinking just about the controller realizing the motion+ works with the wii u that's some crazy stuff.  one demo in mind is the golf where you see the ball on the ground to swing at.  thats totally nuts.

what is the next level for the move?  there really is none.  the best move would be to out kinect kinect but they  wouldnt leave all the current owners high and dry.



Around the Network
dsage01 on 30 December 2011
gameonbro said:
dsage01 said:
gameonbro said:
kinect is #1 for me. why game developers are slow to the table when hacktivist show you street fighter 4, bulletstorm, dead island, star wars force unleashed 2, and even skyrim FUS RO DAH! The sad part is they look better than most kinect games by majors.

Those hacks also proove that with a simple scheme you can make kinect optional games.

Like it or not kinect is a blast with kin. Kinect parties are hella fun that will leave your sides hurting from laughing. Also kinect is the new family member you get to talk to lol...

its not that kinect isnt capable of hardcore the questions are do you want to play them if a developer actually makes one. sega tried with rise of nightmare.

the reason i put kinect #1 is for the mere fact if microsoft add a controller its the perfect package. full body tracking with precision shooting with actual throwing, ducking, reloading etc... oh my. which points out another sony failure. it wouldve been better if they came out with a new eye with the release of move than later.

I was going to give the other 2 a toss up but then i thought about it. we are judging motion + on what its doing for wii. what will it do for the wii u should be the question. with the wii u cam you have move.

As my 4 move controllers sit in a draw waiting for EA to stop being p*SS**s and put out fight night for 2 with 4 actual controllers I realize that might never happen. The developers will always sell move short because most people only have one controller. Now grand slam tennis 2 is all move


So I understand your viewpoint and why Kinect is your number one. But I don't get your number 2 and number 3 at all. If you can elaborate more on those points it can be nice because for WM+ your saying "what can it do for the Wii U" while we have we're just judjing on the controller not the system. For PS Move you want Fight Night to work with 4 controllers. 

i have fight thats why i bought the 4 controllers.  dont really like it.  i just want to float like a butterfly sting like a bee lol...

we are talking about the controller not the games.  so thinking just about the controller realizing the motion+ works with the wii u that's some crazy stuff.  one demo in mind is the golf where you see the ball on the ground to swing at.  thats totally nuts.

what is the next level for the move?  there really is none.  the best move would be to out kinect kinect but they  wouldnt leave all the current owners high and dry.


Wii U hasn't really come out as yet so there's no point bringing in that as we haven't tried gameplay ourselves. Move and Kinect just came out a year ago and are both selling really well. And the point of this thread is to discuss how the 2 motion controllers and kinect work currently. Sure you can mention the future of these things but its not fair to include to include them in your review especially when we don't know when the next installment for every console is releasing. 



sethnintendo on 30 December 2011
kowenicki said:
well motion gamings most popular genres are Dance and Fitness....

Kinect wins both of those quite easily imo.


I suppose Wii Sports and Wii Sports Resort sales are irrelevant.



sethnintendo on 30 December 2011
gameonbro said:


i always laugh at that argument.  especially considering a full move experience was more expensive.  sure you can get away with just the eye and move but to play fight one move is totally lame so you buy 2. that was the price of kinect alone.  do you go with holding a controller or get the navi i got the navi.     so for a 2 player experience i went with the eye bundle 2 navis and 3 additional move.  you do the math.  1 kinect is all you need.

Kinect only supports 2 people still right?  For your argument if you only have 2 people then Kinect is clear winner.  However, if you have more than 2 people then of course a few will have to wait to play. 



bazmeistergen on 30 December 2011

More support for Motion Plus will appear on Wii U.



Yes.

www.spacemag.org - contribute your stuff... satire, comics, ideas, debate, stupidy stupid etc.

Around the Network
bazmeistergen on 30 December 2011

Confused by the point about Donkey Kong Country... it doesn't use Motion Plus at all. It's mainly traditional controls.



Yes.

www.spacemag.org - contribute your stuff... satire, comics, ideas, debate, stupidy stupid etc.

Barozi on 30 December 2011
sethnintendo said:
gameonbro said:


i always laugh at that argument.  especially considering a full move experience was more expensive.  sure you can get away with just the eye and move but to play fight one move is totally lame so you buy 2. that was the price of kinect alone.  do you go with holding a controller or get the navi i got the navi.     so for a 2 player experience i went with the eye bundle 2 navis and 3 additional move.  you do the math.  1 kinect is all you need.

Kinect only supports 2 people still right?  For your argument if you only have 2 people then Kinect is clear winner.  However, if you have more than 2 people then of course a few will have to wait to play. 

Just Dance 3 for Kinect supports 4 players simultaneously.



gameonbro on 30 December 2011
sethnintendo said:
gameonbro said:


i always laugh at that argument.  especially considering a full move experience was more expensive.  sure you can get away with just the eye and move but to play fight one move is totally lame so you buy 2. that was the price of kinect alone.  do you go with holding a controller or get the navi i got the navi.     so for a 2 player experience i went with the eye bundle 2 navis and 3 additional move.  you do the math.  1 kinect is all you need.

Kinect only supports 2 people still right?  For your argument if you only have 2 people then Kinect is clear winner.  However, if you have more than 2 people then of course a few will have to wait to play. 

regardless if you want 4 player with the move your spending way more than kinect.   also jd3 has 4 player.  



Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 on 30 December 2011

Kinect four players? Really.. never heard of it but cool.



Yay!!!