By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - Kinect vs PS Move vs Wii Motion Plus

Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 on 27 December 2011

By Specific Games:

Motion Plus
Kinect
Move

By Accuracy:
Move
Motion Plus
Kinect

Overall:
Kinect (Two kinect games got nominated for VGA awards, DC2 is just pure fun)
Motion Plus (Zelda)
Move (Failed heroes game thing)



Yay!!!

Around the Network
Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 on 27 December 2011
KBG29 said:
Move from a hardware point is number one overall without question. The camera is a win some/loose some situation, but combined with the controllers it is far and away the best. On the traditional games front neither of the competitors are close, and it has proved itself capable on dance and fitness front. Its only issue is a lack of content to this point.

Kinect and Wii Motion + are about =. Motion + gives great controls to the shooter market, and sports, but the dance and fitness genres are lacking without other additions. Kinect is king of dance and fitness but lacks on the traditional front.

I believe the next gen will be an advanced version of move.


It doesnt lack content.. it lacks FUN content



Yay!!!

maximrace on 27 December 2011
yo_john117 said:

The device itself:

1. Move
2. Motion Plus
3. Kinect


The games:

1. Motion Plus
2. Move
3. Kinect


Overall:

1. Move
2. Motion Plus
3. Kinect

Surprised you favor the move :p.



Bail on 27 December 2011

1) Move : great accuracy, great variety of games (Killzone, Socom, Sports Champions, Echocrome 2, etc.)

2) WM + : same as Move, less accurate though

3) Kinect : IMHO no controller means no core game. I don't care for casual games, aka fitness, dancing...



yo_john117 on 27 December 2011
maximrace said:
yo_john117 said:

The device itself:

1. Move
2. Motion Plus
3. Kinect


The games:

1. Motion Plus
2. Move
3. Kinect


Overall:

1. Move
2. Motion Plus
3. Kinect

Surprised you favor the move :p.

Well I've actually have played hardly anything on all of those. I put move up on top because of it's super accuracy and it has support from games that would be a lot of fun to play with (R3, KZ3, Heavy Rain, Ect)



Around the Network
Slimebeast on 27 December 2011
d21lewis said:
As for Kinect--I had(and still have) a house full of visitors for Christmas. Two 20-something guys, Two 20-something girls, an 11 year old boy, my ten year old daughter, and my GF. For the last few nights, my living room looked like a Kinect commercial. I can honestly say that the last few days have been some of the most awesome social gaming I've ever had. Kinect is a winner.

Sounds fun. A testament to the strength of Kenect I would say. You have the most detailed stories as usual. What games did you play?

I hardly have any friends IRL so I would never be able to test motion controls as a true social experience but from my limited experience with all three from game stores and a friends house I would rank them:

1. Move (accuracy)
2. Kinect (because my friend likes it a lot)
3. Wii motion plus (I couldn't make it past the first water hole in Donkey Kong Country).



Ajescent on 27 December 2011

Move is very much underrated in my opinion.



PS One/2/p/3slim/Vita owner. I survived the Apocalyps3/Collaps3 and all I got was this lousy signature.


Xbox One: What are you doing Dave?

Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 on 27 December 2011

Kinect is a wonderful Christmas party device.... DC2 and Kinect Sports Season 2 really did it for me..

We had 5 families over, and a total of 25 people... 14 of which are kids-teenagers...

Kinect sports soccer was fun and so was bowling and golf was pretty stupid LOL... And DC2 was really the heavy hitter, Everyone took turns playing the "noob" or beginner song first "Mai Hee"... Really fun. I showed them of with my friend who also had a kinect DC2.. we both got in to 2 mil EACH doing the "Reach" song on hard... and everyone tried it as well.. really fun.

People coming over again at new years day...

BTW peple didnt leave till it was 2 a.m... I slept at 12 a.m. (Tired)



Yay!!!

d21lewis on 27 December 2011
Slimebeast said:
d21lewis said:
As for Kinect--I had(and still have) a house full of visitors for Christmas. Two 20-something guys, Two 20-something girls, an 11 year old boy, my ten year old daughter, and my GF. For the last few nights, my living room looked like a Kinect commercial. I can honestly say that the last few days have been some of the most awesome social gaming I've ever had. Kinect is a winner.

Sounds fun. A testament to the strength of Kenect I would say. You have the most detailed stories as usual. What games did you play?

I hardly have any friends IRL so I would never be able to test motion controls as a true social experience but from my limited experience with all three from game stores and a friends house I would rank them:

1. Move (accuracy)
2. Kinect (because my friend likes it a lot)
3. Wii motion plus (I couldn't make it past the first water hole in Donkey Kong Country).

Fruit Ninja, Kinect Adventures (kids, mostly), and Dance Central 2.  We also got my GF's nephew a 4GB Kinect 360 from Wal-Mart (which netted me a $100 gift card!).  Best Christmas ever?  I think it was!



Wh1pL4shL1ve_007 on 27 December 2011
d21lewis said:
Slimebeast said:
d21lewis said:
As for Kinect--I had(and still have) a house full of visitors for Christmas. Two 20-something guys, Two 20-something girls, an 11 year old boy, my ten year old daughter, and my GF. For the last few nights, my living room looked like a Kinect commercial. I can honestly say that the last few days have been some of the most awesome social gaming I've ever had. Kinect is a winner.

Sounds fun. A testament to the strength of Kenect I would say. You have the most detailed stories as usual. What games did you play?

I hardly have any friends IRL so I would never be able to test motion controls as a true social experience but from my limited experience with all three from game stores and a friends house I would rank them:

1. Move (accuracy)
2. Kinect (because my friend likes it a lot)
3. Wii motion plus (I couldn't make it past the first water hole in Donkey Kong Country).

Fruit Ninja, Kinect Adventures (kids, mostly), and Dance Central 2.  We also got my GF's nephew a 4GB Kinect 360 from Wal-Mart (which netted me a $100 gift card!).  Best Christmas ever?  I think it was!


Lol, you kept the gift card... a win-win scenario right there...



Yay!!!