Tales of Symphonia and Mirror's Edge are awesome games. I'd go for them. And if you feel like enjoying what technology can achieve these days and you feel in the mood for experiencing a movie, there's Heavy Rain.

Well i just removed all the shit or less then stellar games from the list leaving the decent or amazing games.

What you play second really depends on your personal genre preference.

I personally would go onto BattalionWars it was a hidden gem on GameCube and the sequel was a slight improvement though finding an opponent online will be virtually impossible because the game bombed and nobody was online last time I checked.

The best game if you like RPG's is Tales, hands down.

If you like shooters go with Turok, underated game big time.

Prototype is simply to die for if you like open world games. Better then Infamous and better then Arkham City. It is hands down among the absolute best open world games.

After those the rest of the list is pretty decent, play based on genre preference. ThougI hope you didn't pay anymore then 5$ for any of these games. Most of these games I have seen going for 8.99$ new so used a 5$ price tag is about as much as they are worth.

Tenchu Shadow Assassins is so bad, I couldn't even stomach one level. I got it for $5 a year ago and I still feel ripped off.

Buying used game is a huge crime against humanity haven't you heard??

Heavy Rain Director’s Cut. You must play this game if you own a ps3. Then after that you should play Mirror's Edge.

Really don't know why you bought so many trash games. I would rather play 3amazing games than 20 meh games.

Wow lots of Heavy Rain, Mirror's Edge and Tales. I didn't think I bought so much bad software. The most I spent on one game was the DJ Hero 2 bundle (surprised no one likes that) for $25 and then Tales for $20 and the lowest was onimusha for $1.50 but I checked the prices online and compared them all around and got the best deals. I think I more surprised you don't want me to play the junk games. :)

The Darkness has pretty much the best story and atmosphere of every FPS this gen.
XIII is also tons of fun.

You should play Skies of Arcadia! The graphics aren't fancy (it's a Dreamcast port) but it's an incredible game. If you like games with lots of exploration then you pretty much hit the jackpot.

Skies of Arcadia and Tales of Symphonia, Mirror's Edge and Final Fantasy XII are the best ones from your list imo (out of those I've tried that is).

Really about the Darkness? I personally couldn't bring myself to finish it, and I am a huge fan of FPS genre.

more than sure. Only the WWI part was kinda weird, but the rest was fantastic. The last FPS with a better story was only Half-Life 2.