By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony Discussion - Uncharted 3 Review Thread!

Tagged games:

ils411 said:
Fun facts

1. Metacritic has 71 reviewers for Uncharted 2 that are still to review Uncharted 3
2. Of the 71 reviews, 26 gave Uncharted 2 perfect scores
3. Metacritic lists 14 new critics for Uncharted 3 that are not listed for Uncharted 2
4. Of this 14 new critics 2 gave U3 80 and 6 gave U3 perfect scores.

I doubt we'll see all of the 71 critics review UC3.. I just doubt it.

I hope we'll see enough to throw in 10/10's in order to keep 94 though xD.

ALSO, the 2 that gave UC3 80 and the 6 that cave U3 a perfect scores are not really balanced. If you remove the 2 80's and 5 10's, UC3 will most likely be higher, and even if not; its a lot easier to go higher with 95+. The 80 REALLY brings a game down. The 10 just takes it up a biit. Right now its barely hanging on to 94 for every 10 and 9.. Imagine another 8!



Around the Network
Aldro said:

[Updated] Big Sites left:



OPM US

OPM AU

Worth Playing

Gamer 2.0

Play.tm

DarkZero

Gamervision

RealGamer

Kombo

Gamer's Hell

AceGamez

Gamesstyle

GameShark

GamerNode

Digital Chumps

Game Revolution

Impulse Gamer

MEgamer

Total Playstation

Console Monster

Techboyz

Da GameBoyz

Games MAster UK

Salute Games

ArmChair Empire

CD-Action

PALGN

Cynamite 9.5

The A.VClub

Brightunes

Extreme Gamer

GRYonline

2Critic Tech

Digital Spy

D+DPAD MAg


I mean the list with the sites left :)



Game of the year 2017 so far:

5. Resident Evil VII
4. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
3. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy
2. Horizon Zero Dawn
1. Super Mario Odyssey

ghettoglamour said:
Aldro said:

[Updated] Big Sites left:



OPM US

OPM AU

Worth Playing

Gamer 2.0

Play.tm

DarkZero

Gamervision

RealGamer

Kombo

Gamer's Hell

AceGamez

Gamesstyle

GameShark

GamerNode

Digital Chumps

Game Revolution

Impulse Gamer

MEgamer

Total Playstation

Console Monster

Techboyz

Da GameBoyz

Games MAster UK

Salute Games

ArmChair Empire

CD-Action

PALGN

Cynamite 9.5

The A.VClub

Brightunes

Extreme Gamer

GRYonline

2Critic Tech

Digital Spy

D+DPAD MAg


I mean the list with the sites left :)

Oh thanks!

 

[Updated] Big Sites left:



OPM US

OPM AU

Worth Playing

Gamer 2.0

Play.tm

DarkZero

Gamervision

RealGamer

Kombo

Gamer's Hell 

Gamesstyle

GameShark

GamerNode

Digital Chumps

Game Revolution

Impulse Gamer

MEgamer

Total Playstation

Console Monster

Techboyz

Da GameBoyz

Games MAster UK

Salute Games

ArmChair Empire

CD-Action

PALGN

Cynamite 9.5

The A.VClub

Brightunes

Extreme Gamer

GRYonline

2Critic Tech

Digital Spy

D+DPAD MAg



Aldro said:
Dr.Grass said:
I'm sorry, but this thread is turning out into a pathetic mess.

Reminds of of teenage girls freaking out and almost dying when they saw the Beetles. Some of you guys here have really lost my respect with your ridiculous excitement of,

''OMG ITS UP TO 94 AGAIN GO! ND GO! GO! GO!!!!''

You are (some of you at least) grown men ffs.

How will ANYONE take any debate with you seriously after acting like this I do not know. I pity people who are legitimate 360 fans on this site - I'm starting to see what they have to go through.

Hm.. don't take this the wrong way;
But I couldn't care less about how ANYONE sees me on these or any boards online.

 

:>


Some comments on that:

- Your comment is fair enough.

- Don't know how I could 'take it in the wrong way'

- Still funny that you replied even though I didn't mention your name

- You have been somewhat comic (and thereby entertaining)  in this thread and I have found certain other users to be actually obnoxious.

- Even tough I said your comment is fair, I need to add that ''I couldn't care less about how ANYONE sees me'' is a statement that is often made but rarely, if ever, true.



Dr.Grass said:
Aldro said:
Dr.Grass said:
I'm sorry, but this thread is turning out into a pathetic mess.

Reminds of of teenage girls freaking out and almost dying when they saw the Beetles. Some of you guys here have really lost my respect with your ridiculous excitement of,

''OMG ITS UP TO 94 AGAIN GO! ND GO! GO! GO!!!!''

You are (some of you at least) grown men ffs.

How will ANYONE take any debate with you seriously after acting like this I do not know. I pity people who are legitimate 360 fans on this site - I'm starting to see what they have to go through.

Hm.. don't take this the wrong way;
But I couldn't care less about how ANYONE sees me on these or any boards online.

 

:>


Some comments on that:

- Your comment is fair enough.

- Don't know how I could 'take it in the wrong way'

- Still funny that you replied even though I didn't mention your name

- You have been somewhat comic (and thereby entertaining)  in this thread and I have found certain other users to be actually obnoxious.

- Even tough I said your comment is fair, I need to add that ''I couldn't care less about how ANYONE sees me'' is a statement that is often made but rarely, if ever, true.

Well you're just going to have to take my word for it now, don't you? <3

I replied because I felt hit because I don't care and anyone that's known me for a while does know how I want to be seen by others.
"Reminds of of teenage girls freaking out and almost dying when they saw the Beetles. Some of you guys here have really lost my respect with your ridiculous excitement of, OMG its back to 94"
Thats me, in and out of a nut hole ^_^! Im even telling you, so go ahead and erase your respect for me because I'm not bothered at all XD.



Around the Network
Dr.Grass said:
I'm sorry, but this thread is turning out into a pathetic mess.

Reminds of of teenage girls freaking out and almost dying when they saw the Beetles. Some of you guys here have really lost my respect with your ridiculous excitement of,

''OMG ITS UP TO 94 AGAIN GO! ND GO! GO! GO!!!!''

You are (some of you at least) grown men ffs.

How will ANYONE take any debate with you seriously after acting like this I do not know. I pity people who are legitimate 360 fans on this site - I'm starting to see what they have to go through.

LOL you are so adult .



ethomaz said:
Dr.Grass said:
I'm sorry, but this thread is turning out into a pathetic mess.

Reminds of of teenage girls freaking out and almost dying when they saw the Beetles. Some of you guys here have really lost my respect with your ridiculous excitement of,

''OMG ITS UP TO 94 AGAIN GO! ND GO! GO! GO!!!!''

You are (some of you at least) grown men ffs.

How will ANYONE take any debate with you seriously after acting like this I do not know. I pity people who are legitimate 360 fans on this site - I'm starting to see what they have to go through.

LOL you are so adult .

Bro, could you check what avg Batman Arkham City on the 360 is on?
Quite curious to see .. (even though this thread is about Uncharted)



Aldro said:

Bro, could you check what avg Batman Arkham City on the 360 is on?
Quite curious to see .. (even though this thread is about Uncharted)

I made it yesterday in another thread

- Batman: AC (PS3) has 26 reviews and by my math the avg. 95.8... Metacritic rounded it up to 96.
- Batman: AC (360) has 56 reviews and by my math the avg. 94.55... Metacritic rounded it up to 95.

I didn't check if more reviews was added.



Batman clearly got that 96/95 because of its unexpected quality, just the opposite of Uncharted 3, which became a victim of its own hype in some cases.

Batman may win the metascore, but I really see Uncharted 3 as the stronger candidate for GOTY.
I mean, is there a single quote that says something like "Batman is the best game of this gen"...?



Game of the year 2017 so far:

5. Resident Evil VII
4. Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
3. Uncharted: The Lost Legacy
2. Horizon Zero Dawn
1. Super Mario Odyssey

ethomaz said:

Aldro said:

 Bro, could you check what avg Batman Arkham City on the 360 is on?
Quite curious to see .. (even though this thread is about Uncharted)

I made it yesterday in another thread

- Batman: AC (PS3) has 26 reviews and by my math the avg. 95.8... Metacritic rounded it up to 96.
- Batman: AC (360) has 56 reviews and by my math the avg. 94.55... Metacritic rounded it up to 95.

I didn't check if more reviews was added.

Since the 360 version has about the same as Uncharted, judging by that, theres only 0.45ish between them!
Dislike how Batman gets rounded up to 95 and if Uncharted is 93,90 its down to 93 >_>.

 

@Ghettoglamour
I believe you hit the nail there. It's true what you said.