By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Xbox 360 Vs. Playstation 3 2012 - *February* Update

Seece said:
1.9? That's higher than any X360 NPD in history, despite Nov 11 PS3 being 470k lower than Nov 10 X360. You really do come out with some laughable crap postoffice


You want to compare PS3 to 360 in the United States? Fine. In 2008 360 sold 836k in November NPD (Gears of War 2 launch) and went on to sell 1440k in December. As I mentioned above PS3 always has better November to December comparisons.



Proudest Platinums:
1. Gran Turismo 5
2. Persona 4 Arena
3. Wipeout HD
4. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2
5. Super Street Fighter 4

Around the Network
postofficebuddy said:
Seece said:
1.9? That's higher than any X360 NPD in history, despite Nov 11 PS3 being 470k lower than Nov 10 X360. You really do come out with some laughable crap postoffice


You want to compare PS3 to 360 in the United States? Fine. In 2008 360 sold 836k in November NPD (Gears of War 2 launch) and went on to sell 1440k in December. As I mentioned above PS3 always has better November to December comparisons.

Wanna make a small bet? no wager, I'm not 12. I bet 360 will have a higher increase over Nov than PS3, you bet the opposite?

07 and 08 X360 increased it's lead over PS3 in Dec more so than it did in Nov. Last year there were shortages, and 09 was the year of the $100 price cut, they were basically neck and neck.



 

Seece said:
postofficebuddy said:
Seece said:
1.9? That's higher than any X360 NPD in history, despite Nov 11 PS3 being 470k lower than Nov 10 X360. You really do come out with some laughable crap postoffice


You want to compare PS3 to 360 in the United States? Fine. In 2008 360 sold 836k in November NPD (Gears of War 2 launch) and went on to sell 1440k in December. As I mentioned above PS3 always has better November to December comparisons.

Wanna make a small bet? no wager, I'm not 12. I bet 360 will have a higher increase over Nov than PS3, you bet the opposite?

07 and 08 X360 increased it's lead over PS3 in Dec more so than it did in Nov. Last year there were shortages, and 09 was the year of the $100 price cut, they were basically neck and neck.


I don't make wagers, it's against my religion (although I'm not exactly devout). Are you talking about percentage increase or absolute increase? The former, not even remotely close. The latter, probably relatively close. I'd give 360 about a 20% chance of having a better absolute increase.



Proudest Platinums:
1. Gran Turismo 5
2. Persona 4 Arena
3. Wipeout HD
4. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2
5. Super Street Fighter 4

Seece said:
postofficebuddy said:
Seece said:
1.9? That's higher than any X360 NPD in history, despite Nov 11 PS3 being 470k lower than Nov 10 X360. You really do come out with some laughable crap postoffice


You want to compare PS3 to 360 in the United States? Fine. In 2008 360 sold 836k in November NPD (Gears of War 2 launch) and went on to sell 1440k in December. As I mentioned above PS3 always has better November to December comparisons.

Wanna make a small bet? no wager, I'm not 12. I bet 360 will have a higher increase over Nov than PS3, you bet the opposite?

07 and 08 X360 increased it's lead over PS3 in Dec more so than it did in Nov. Last year there were shortages, and 09 was the year of the $100 price cut, they were basically neck and neck.

You are right about 360 having a bigger increase in the US this Dec, but it has nothing to do with history at all, but kinect and the resurgence of the console. But the PS3 will once again sell enough to stay afloat.



 Next Gen 

11/20/09 04:25 makingmusic476 Warning Other (Your avatar is borderline NSFW. Please keep it for as long as possible.)

Lol, are you both ignoring past Nov/Dec NPD's then? yes history IS on my side.

In Nov 07 X360 outsold PS3 by 300k~, then in Dec it increased that to 460k~
In Nov 08 X360 outsold PS3 by 460k~, then in Dec it increased that to 715k~
In Nov 09 Xbox outsold PS3 by 110k~, then in Dec lost 50k to PS3, this overall was a close holiday though.
In Nov 10 X360 outsold PS3 by 840k~, then in Dec it decreased to 650k~ but it had shortages through December.



 

Around the Network
Seece said:
Lol, are you both ignoring past Nov/Dec NPD's then? yes history IS on my side.

In Nov 07 X360 outsold PS3 by 300k~, then in Dec it increased that to 460k~
In Nov 08 X360 outsold PS3 by 460k~, then in Dec it increased that to 715k~
In Nov 09 Xbox outsold PS3 by 110k~, then in Dec lost 50k to PS3, this overall was a close holiday though.
In Nov 10 X360 outsold PS3 by 840k~, then in Dec it decreased to 650k~ but it had shortages through December.


So this means that starting from this week the 360 has to outsell the PS3 by a larger margin then it ever did in december with already one third of the month gone. And to do this those first few days of december are far more important for the 360 the the last week or so since the PS3 took it the last two years.

I think it's gonna be too little too late.



2 weeks of sales to go.

With all this talk of betting, would anyone dare to post their odds?
Not for actual cash money betting, but for an interesting mini market?

What the odds?



YEAR OF THE.........



JimmyDanger said:
2 weeks of sales to go.

With all this talk of betting, would anyone dare to post their odds?
Not for actual cash money betting, but for an interesting mini market?

What the odds?

3 weeks of sales actually 

Dec 17th

Dec 24th

Dec 31st



yo_john117 said:
JimmyDanger said:
2 weeks of sales to go.

With all this talk of betting, would anyone dare to post their odds?
Not for actual cash money betting, but for an interesting mini market?

What the odds?

3 weeks of sales actually 

Dec 17th

Dec 24th

Dec 31st


Most people assume PS3 will win or tie 360 the last week of the year because of Boxing Day in Europe and sales peaking in Japan and dropping off dramatically in America.



Proudest Platinums:
1. Gran Turismo 5
2. Persona 4 Arena
3. Wipeout HD
4. Ninja Gaiden Sigma 2
5. Super Street Fighter 4