By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - The Top 100 TV Shows - The Results!

sapphi_snake on 10 October 2011
archbrix said:
Bunyip said:
sapphi_snake said:

#1. Lots of people vote several times on that site to make sure their faves get the score they want it to get. It's full of fanboys, so that says nothing. You'd also have to conduct a survey on a more diverse group to get a better ideea of what people think of Lost.

#2. Lots of people are incapable of forming a critical opinion. Te critics average went below 80 for the 5th season, and Lost's finale was panned (which it deserved, as it was cheap, mediocre, melodramatic nonsense).

That season still has far more great critic reviews than bad, and still only fell to a 78, which certainly doesn't "suck" on anyone elses scale, lol.

Yup.  Just leave it... haters gonna hate. 

One of the typical things people with uncritical opinions say (e.g. tween girls who love Twilight).



"I don't understand how someone could like Tolstoy and Dostoyevsky, but not like Twilight!!!"

"Last book I read was Brokeback Mountain, I just don't have the patience for them unless it's softcore porn."

                                                                               (The Voice of a Generation and Seece)

"If you cant stand the sound of your own voice than dont become a singer !!!!!"

                                                                               (pizzahut451)

Around the Network
maximus22 on 10 October 2011

Hey I got the top 3 right! Congrats to LOST, perhaps the most brilliantly written show of all time.

P.S. To people whining about lost winning: don't give me sh*t for saying that, tis only my opinion.



archbrix on 10 October 2011
maximus22 said:

Hey I got the top 3 right! Congrats to LOST, perhaps the most brilliantly written show of all time.

P.S. To people whining about lost winning: don't give me sh*t for saying that, tis only my opinion.

Sorry, but your opinion is officially WRONG!  (jk, of course) 



Bunyip on 10 October 2011
sapphi_snake said:
archbrix said:
Bunyip said:
sapphi_snake said:

#1. Lots of people vote several times on that site to make sure their faves get the score they want it to get. It's full of fanboys, so that says nothing. You'd also have to conduct a survey on a more diverse group to get a better ideea of what people think of Lost.

#2. Lots of people are incapable of forming a critical opinion. Te critics average went below 80 for the 5th season, and Lost's finale was panned (which it deserved, as it was cheap, mediocre, melodramatic nonsense).

That season still has far more great critic reviews than bad, and still only fell to a 78, which certainly doesn't "suck" on anyone elses scale, lol.

Yup.  Just leave it... haters gonna hate. 

One of the typical things people with uncritical opinions say (e.g. tween girls who love Twilight).

Talk about a typical response, lol.

And he's not a tween girl, he's 36 years old!  :p



archbrix on 10 October 2011
Bunyip said:
sapphi_snake said:
archbrix said:
Bunyip said:
sapphi_snake said:

#1. Lots of people vote several times on that site to make sure their faves get the score they want it to get. It's full of fanboys, so that says nothing. You'd also have to conduct a survey on a more diverse group to get a better ideea of what people think of Lost.

#2. Lots of people are incapable of forming a critical opinion. Te critics average went below 80 for the 5th season, and Lost's finale was panned (which it deserved, as it was cheap, mediocre, melodramatic nonsense).

That season still has far more great critic reviews than bad, and still only fell to a 78, which certainly doesn't "suck" on anyone elses scale, lol.

Yup.  Just leave it... haters gonna hate. 

One of the typical things people with uncritical opinions say (e.g. tween girls who love Twilight).

Talk about a typical response, lol.

And he's not a tween girl, he's 36 years old!  :p

  That's right... I'm a full grown woman, dammit!



Around the Network
naruball on 10 October 2011

Gotta love the internet. I get that everyone's is entitled their own opinion, but some comments are laughable (not just on this thread, but in comment sections and forums in general). Calling Lost "garbage" or saying that it "sucked" is by all means an exaggeration.
I personally never liked shows like CSI, NCIS, Criminal Minds, House, Grey's Anatomy etc, but I would never say they suck. You know why? Because they don't. They're just not my cup of tea.



Tony_Stark on 10 October 2011
archbrix said:
Tony_Stark said:
archbrix said:
Level1Death said:
Lost won. Just goes to show you that people are willing to watch garbage.

Lol, bitter much?

Seriously, saying it's not one of your favs, or even overrated is one thing.

But calling something the calibur of LOST garbage?  You're certainly in the vast, vast minority.

No, no he's not. 

Yes, yes he is...

http://www.metacritic.com/tv/lost/season-1/user-reviews

Despite a few mediocre and even a couple of negative opinions, both the meta and user averages remain pleasantly high... and far from "garbage". 

No, no he really isn't. To say he is in the "vast vast minority" is naive at best. With only 109 reviews, it is safe to say that a tiny minority of people even bothered to post a review, thus rendering your point moot. 



"with great power, comes great responsibility."

Marks on 10 October 2011

Ahhhh fuck LOST! That show sucked ass after the first season.

Oh well at least Dexter got #2. That show is as good now in Season 6 as it was in Season 1.



Moren on 10 October 2011

ermmmmm OK I'll just say I respectfully disagree.



archbrix on 10 October 2011
Tony_Stark said:
archbrix said:
Tony_Stark said:

No, no he's not. 

Yes, yes he is...

http://www.metacritic.com/tv/lost/season-1/user-reviews

Despite a few mediocre and even a couple of negative opinions, both the meta and user averages remain pleasantly high... and far from "garbage". 

No, no he really isn't. To say he is in the "vast vast minority" is naive at best. With only 109 reviews, it is safe to say that a tiny minority of people even bothered to post a review, thus rendering your point moot. 

You're obviously missing the point...

Regardless of how many reviews there were, more of those people liked the show than didn't.  And of the ones who didn't, few cried "sucked" or "garbage", which is my point.  And I've heard very few legit critics call the show such disparaging remarks.  So unless you have evidence to the contrary, take out one of the "vasts" if you like and my point is still valid.

Even on this thread, there's what, four of you that say it sucks?  While many may claim they don't care about it, or even don't like it, again it's the minority that claim that it's trash.  You're all perfectly entitled to your opinions; just don't pretend that the majority agrees with you...