By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Politics - USA has the highest incarceration rate. Why?

MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Alby_da_Wolf said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Marks said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Marks said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
because of racial profiling


I hope that's a joke.

 

And my answer to the OP's question is like the Clash said in the song "I'm So Bored With the USA"...because killers in America work 7 days a week. i.e. Americans commit a shit ton of crime. 

Well that and because cops in America seem like dicks from what I've seen on shows like Cops. They arrest people just to look tough and show their authority. People get arrested for having small amounts of pot, underage drinking, etc. They need to focus on major crimes like murder, rape, theft, etc. and less on harmless crimes like pot posession and underage drinking, etc. 

why the guy with the coolest shirt ever? why man?

no i'm not joking.

Well it is undeniable that there's racism in the US but I just don't think that's why there's such a high incarceration rate in the US. 

Could you expand on your point though about racial profiling leading to higher incarceration rates please? Are you talking about policemen being racist and arresting people based on colour...or are you talking more about the court system sentencing people based on race?

both in a way. i understand theres more to it then that, but why are more then 80% of jail's in every state filled with minorities? i don't beleive half that percentage commit crimes.

i agree with your first post.

I don't believe it either: here in Italy with have a lot of immigrants, they are a lot, but they are minorities anyway, and while illegal ones have higher than average crime rates, regular ones have lower ones, they are actually more honest than the Italian average. Minorities integrated in the society for decennia or even centuries should have around the same crime rate of the majority, unless there be still forms of discrimination, both in the way they are judged and in the opportunities they are given to get a decent life. And one thing I never understood is why no big mafia boss has ever been sentenced to death in USA. Just this fact should force any honest judge to apply death penalty only to the worst serial killers, otherwise there wouldn't be equal treatment between the common thug that killed one person during a robbery and is sentenced to death and the boss that ordered many killings and countless other crimes, but receives a milder penalty.

are you talking about my post or the OP.

I talk and agree about what you wrote about crime rates in the minorities: they shouldn't be higher than average, if the integration is good they should actually have the same or even lower (that's the case of regular immigrants that came looking for a job, so being by definition all people looking for a honest way to earn a living) crime rates than the majority. The digression about mafia bosses was because it makes me suspect that justice isn't so just if they receive milder penalties than members of minorities that committed a lot less homicides and other crimes than them, but are sentenced to death because they can't pay a good lawyer.



Stwike him, Centuwion. Stwike him vewy wuffly! (Pontius Pilate, "Life of Brian")
A fart without stink is like a sky without stars.
TGS, Third Grade Shooter: brand new genre invented by Kevin Butler exclusively for Natal WiiToo Kinect. PEW! PEW-PEW-PEW! 
 


Around the Network
Alby_da_Wolf said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Alby_da_Wolf said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Marks said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
Marks said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
because of racial profiling


I hope that's a joke.

 

And my answer to the OP's question is like the Clash said in the song "I'm So Bored With the USA"...because killers in America work 7 days a week. i.e. Americans commit a shit ton of crime. 

Well that and because cops in America seem like dicks from what I've seen on shows like Cops. They arrest people just to look tough and show their authority. People get arrested for having small amounts of pot, underage drinking, etc. They need to focus on major crimes like murder, rape, theft, etc. and less on harmless crimes like pot posession and underage drinking, etc. 

why the guy with the coolest shirt ever? why man?

no i'm not joking.

Well it is undeniable that there's racism in the US but I just don't think that's why there's such a high incarceration rate in the US. 

Could you expand on your point though about racial profiling leading to higher incarceration rates please? Are you talking about policemen being racist and arresting people based on colour...or are you talking more about the court system sentencing people based on race?

both in a way. i understand theres more to it then that, but why are more then 80% of jail's in every state filled with minorities? i don't beleive half that percentage commit crimes.

i agree with your first post.

I don't believe it either: here in Italy with have a lot of immigrants, they are a lot, but they are minorities anyway, and while illegal ones have higher than average crime rates, regular ones have lower ones, they are actually more honest than the Italian average. Minorities integrated in the society for decennia or even centuries should have around the same crime rate of the majority, unless there be still forms of discrimination, both in the way they are judged and in the opportunities they are given to get a decent life. And one thing I never understood is why no big mafia boss has ever been sentenced to death in USA. Just this fact should force any honest judge to apply death penalty only to the worst serial killers, otherwise there wouldn't be equal treatment between the common thug that killed one person during a robbery and is sentenced to death and the boss that ordered many killings and countless other crimes, but receives a milder penalty.

are you talking about my post or the OP.

I talk and agree about what you wrote about crime rates in the minorities: they shouldn't be higher than average, if the integration is good they should actually have the same or even lower (that's the case of regular immigrants that came looking for a job, so being by definition all people looking for a honest way to earn a living) crime rates than the majority. The digression about mafia bosses was because it makes me suspect that justice isn't so just if they receive milder penalties than members of minorities that committed a lot less homicides and other crimes than them, but are sentenced to death because they can't pay a good lawyer.

cool. spot on.

side note: gamescom looks like its starting. there seating everyone at the Sony confrence:http://blog.eu.playstation.com/2011/08/16/watch-the-gamescom-press-conference-live/



d21lewis said:
ArnoldRimmer said:
There are two major reasons:

1. The main reason is that american jails are filled with harmless drug users, not real criminals who harm others.

2. Locking people up is a business in the USA. So there are many people who will earn more money if more people are locked up, so these influential people have an interest to have as many people in jail as possible.


I don't know about prisons, but I know from working as a jailer that it actually costs a ton of money to clothe, feed, house, and protect prisoners.  And God forbid somebody need medical attention.  There goes a huge chunk of our budget, right there! 

There's a reason why people get suspended sentences or get to spend their time confined to their homes.  If anybody is making money, it's the probation office.  Rather than go to jail (and possibly prison), offenders have to report to their probation office and pay a pre-determined fee (as well as adhere to a certain set of rules).  Of course, EVERYBODY would rather be on probation than actually go to jail/prison. --Unfortunately, people on probation always seem to fuck it up and get arrested or fail to report, anyway.  We called probation "A jail sentence on lay-away" because people on probation always end up going to jail for probation violations.


I know in New York most cops love to find someone that is on Probation/Parole so they can arrest them on a false charge to send them to jail. I mean if you're on Parole/Probation walking in a group larger then two people will get you stopped, questioned and maybe even searched in my city. This also goes for being in a vehicle...including a cab/taxi. Cops here are truly assholes and are usually bored, which is funny because when something actually happens they're the last on the scene.



Love the product, not the company. They love your money, not you.

-TheRealMafoo

DeathToIran24 said:
Too many blacks and latinos.

bad argument

im not sure whether your joking or not, but jail's and prisions in 49 of the 50 states do have 80%-90% minorities in them. its more of a currupt system then then any one race so your statement is highly flaw'd.

 

 



MARCUSDJACKSON said:
DeathToIran24 said:
Too many blacks and latinos.

bad argument

im not sure whether your joking or not, but jail's and prisions in 49 of the 50 states do have 80%-90% minorities in them. its more of a currupt system then then any one race so your statement is highly flaw'd.

 

 


After reading the other post (the one that said 80% minorities), I went to google and tried to find a graph to refute your statement.  I found so much confilicting information that I just said fuck it.  Some graphs, pie charts, and reports supported the claim.  Others totally contradicted it.  Most had whites at about 1/3 and black at 1/3 with Hispanics, Indians, and other making up the final third.  Still, considering that blacks are only 13-18% of the United States population, that was still pretty bad.  Another that I stumbled across said that 1 of every 10 blacks would go to jail and yet another showed that close to 75% of inmates on death row were white.

There's a lot of variables (shameless plug for Rocketpig's comic, Variables.  Check it out at www.selfcentent.com ) that we aren't taking into account in this thread and we probably won't take the time to sort things out.  It's not as black and white as we may think it is.



Around the Network
Seece said:
vlad321 said:
Seece said:
ArnoldRimmer said:
There are two major reasons:

1. The main reason is that american jails are filled with harmless drug users, not real criminals who harm others.

2. Locking people up is a business in the USA. So there are many people who will earn more money if more people are locked up, so these influential people have an interest to have as many people in jail as possible.

I've never understood how America makes money out of prisoners? Here it's the opposite so we try to keep people out of prisons and reduce their sentances.

America doesn't, but here some prisons are run by corporations which make money out of having prisoners.

lol how?! Do they send them to work or something?

Many do. They get money for every prisoner from the government, and by selling the prisoner's manpower they earn even more (because the prisoners get little to no money for the work of course), so they acually earn twice per prisoner.

In 2009, it was revealed that two(!!!) american judges had received millions of dollars of bribe money from private jails for simply sentencing as many people as possible to jail for a long time. So it's easy to see how profitable this business must be for the corporations running private jails. By buying stocks from these corporations, actually anyone can profit from the practice of jailing as many people as possible.

Nowadays most big companies use prisoner work, for example: IBM, Boeing, Motorola, Microsoft, AT&T, Wireless, Texas Instrument, Dell, Compaq, Honeywell, Hewlett-Packard, Nortel, Lucent Technologies, 3Com, Intel, Northerm Telecom, TWA, Nordstrom, Revon, Macy's, Pierre Cardin, Target Stores. Callcenter agent for example is a very typical prisoner work as far as I know.

I just remember that the topic was for example portrayed in the great movie Shawshank Redemption that was set back in the 1950s. The prison warden was secretly making a fortune selling prisoner manpower, and the public even applauded him because he pretended that the real reason was that this way the anti-social criminals would give something back to society.



as far as i know by the vast majority the most of the people in jail in america are from drug violations and i believe the main drug in question here is marijuana... funny enough alcohol is an example of a dangerous substance that the over consumption of which causes several deaths per year and yet marijuana is considered by law to be more harmful



DeathToIran24 said:
Too many blacks and latinos.


maybe the whites shouldn't have dragged other people from their homes to america to force them to do their work for them... and funny enough later on we get people like you who make comments like this...



d21lewis said:
MARCUSDJACKSON said:
DeathToIran24 said:
Too many blacks and latinos.

bad argument

im not sure whether your joking or not, but jail's and prisions in 49 of the 50 states do have 80%-90% minorities in them. its more of a currupt system then then any one race so your statement is highly flaw'd.

 

 


After reading the other post (the one that said 80% minorities), I went to google and tried to find a graph to refute your statement.  I found so much confilicting information that I just said fuck it.  Some graphs, pie charts, and reports supported the claim.  Others totally contradicted it.  Most had whites at about 1/3 and black at 1/3 with Hispanics, Indians, and other making up the final third.  Still, considering that blacks are only 13-18% of the United States population, that was still pretty bad.  Another that I stumbled across said that 1 of every 10 blacks would go to jail and yet another showed that close to 75% of inmates on death row were white.

There's a lot of variables (shameless plug for Rocketpig's comic, Variables.  Check it out at www.selfcentent.com ) that we aren't taking into account in this thread and we probably won't take the time to sort things out.  It's not as black and white as we may think it is.

have you finish: aw never mind i'll ask later lol.

i know somethings are missing from my statement, the facts, and the rest of the post in this thread so i think i'm done with this thread. i got to many friends here and could easily make enemies of noobs.

see ya in a thread with less of, well, this.



o_O.Q said:
DeathToIran24 said:
Too many blacks and latinos.


maybe the whites shouldn't have dragged other people from their homes to america to force them to do their work for them... and funny enough later on we get people like you who make comments like this...

dito. i also agree with your other post.

now to leave this thread for good before i lose it. no need to get bannd i made a full yr.