Heavy rain for me.
Alan wake had some great moments too but the rest of the game became repetitive too quickly.

Okay it looks like PS3 excluisves are dominating the 360 ones here. I gotta make this even somehow.

Hmm difficult but I go with Alan Wake because the special edition is quite nice :).

Resistance 2 vs Halo Reach - Halo Reach
Metal Gear Solid 4 vs Gears of War 2 - Metal Gear Solid 4
Gran Turismo 5 vs Forza 3 - Gran Turismo 5
Heavy Rain vs Alan Wake -
God of War 3 vs Fable 3 -
Resisttance Fall of Man vs Gears of War -
Uncharted DF vs Mass Effect -
Killzone 3 vs Left 4 dead 2 -
Warhawk vs Halo 3 -
PGR4 vs Motorstorm Pasific Rift -
Killzone 2 vs Left 4 Dead -
Uncharted 2 vs Mass Effect 2

Made a list of all the games in the first round

Heavy Rain had me off my seat when I was in the car scene. Man what a rush! I was like OMG!

I didn't like either game. I beat heavy rain though.

Both were dissapointing for me. Because each of those studios last gen games were superior imo.

mass effect 2 is mutiplat its on both ps3 and xbox so you might wanna rethink that

every gaming forums are dominated by PS3 fans its not fair... :P

i know, and in real life too :(

Well the best you can do is vote for the game you like. Me and you can't change the world now can we.