This game will have great legs .Great game after what I have heard ,and with the downloadable content it will get better and better .It will sell for all 2008 you will see .

 *pats Rocketpig's back a bit too enthusiastically*

I don't think it is a flop honestly. Given the price of the game, and how well it has done so far it would be hard to ever call it a flop at this point, but as I said, I do think its legs could very well vanish early next year. 

I am not trying to make a prediction or anything, just saying that some people get a bit too cought up in holiday numbers and start thinking that this is normal when it truly isn't.  RB is the type of game you buy for X-mas and is at a price point that is a lot easier to swallow at X-mas, sales will likely be slow during the winter months at least until the Wii release which will probably be a nice boost for all RB sales.

The price point means that it'll likely have strong legs because this is not a game that you can simply rush out and get immediately. Its a game that has good word of mouth and is sufficiently different from GH to warrant to appeal to the audience that already owns GH. Couple in some fun multiplayer and you have a game that should have good legs during the year and a strong second holiday.

all of my mates and my brother learned instruments for real and they're all in Bands for real - so much more rewarding than Rock Band / GH type games.

Whatever happened to the world?

Rock Band I doubt can ever sell consoles. It can only sell well at the holidays. It's the kind of thing you get for XMAS or birthday as your big present,  not something to go with your console.

Guitar Hero is cheap enough to buy casually. That's why I think GH will easily beat Rock Band, even though RB is probably very fun if you have a party going. 

Rock Band, a flop? It recieved higher reviews on Game Rankings, than any Guitar Hero game. What does that tell you?

I just played this game for 14 hours straight. I can't even describe how crazy-addictive it is.

Damn you, Harmonix. Damn you to Hell.

Not a flop in any way, but I do think recent sales have been mostly because of Christmas presents. We'll see in the new year.

X360 version is doing good with 500k+ sold already and keeping strong legs... The PS3 version however, is indeed a flop! Not even at 150k pfff...