I agree, they are awesome. But as I said to Machina, I would only place The Orange Box in the Top 5. The other games seperately just feel like parts of a full package. And they're too short

And by putting all those games on the list, it goes directly against what they said in the first paragraph, if you read it

Obviously it wasn't a perfect list to any of us, but at least 7 of the their top 20 would definitely be in my top 20 as well:

In no particular order:

Resident Evil 4

Zelda: A Link to the Past

Zelda: Wind Waker

Bioshock

Super Mario 3

Super Metroid

Uncharted 2

And Super Mario Galaxy and Final Fantasy 6 would probably be right outside of it.

The only one I really had a problem with in their top 20 was Grand Theft Auto 4.

Troll: Portal is crap.

#49 MGS 3: Snake Eater < #47 AC II ---> WTF is this shit!!!!

#35 - Castlevania: Symphony of the Night < #34 - Left 4 Dead 2 --> xD

#31 - Ico < #18 - Resident Evil 4 --> Are you fucking kidding me?

#4 - Grand Theft Auto IV --> LOL

#1 - Portal --> OMG

Pretty much agreed, although I can see support for Res 4, people loved the shit outta that game.  But yeah, the #1 is my biggest problem...

*edit*

No.  I do not like this list.

Where's that gimmick thread again? That's the problem with Portal to me. It introduces an interesting gameplay mechanic, and then it's nothing but rinse and repeat the rest of the way through the game.

Rockstar overrepresented as well, and that's saying a lot when they only have two games on the list, one of which has no business being there and the other of which is probably the worst entry since its series went into 3D.

DuckTales making top 100 is great. I mean I loved that game growing up. However most of that list I disagree with which is expected.

RE4 > Ico.

No one played Ico. Thus, no one cared about it.

hmmm, they say the zelda series and gta series are diverse.  dont get me wrong, they are both great series.  they do add alot of content from game to game, but they arent very diverse imo.