By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales - PS3 vs Xbox 360 exclusive sales! (Games that came after 2008 Jan 1st)

Boutros on 18 March 2011

Why 6 games this time? lol



Around the Network
ethomaz on 18 March 2011
NotStan said:
ethomaz said:
NotStan said:

Games missing so far:

Kinect Adventures,

Left 4 Dead 2,

Fable 2,

Fable 3.

Those are just the games that you've purposely turned a blind eye to between the 1st and the 6th place on 360.

Suprisingly you've also missed out Uncharted: Drake's Fortune, I have no idea what the cap is at.. But the Drake's Fortune is 7th if you add it in.

Why?

Kinect Adventures and Fable II ok but the others are not exclusives.

PS. Leaf for Dead in the list is not exclusive.


If L4D is on his list and matches his supposed criteria, then so are the games that I have listed, OP needs to do more research or set appropriate guidelines.

I agree.



yo_john117 on 18 March 2011
Kynes said:

Why CGI should do them, when this guy was the one who made the first of this type? Let him cherry pick whatever he wants.

Cause CGI knows how to do them up right without cherry picking.



dsage01 on 18 March 2011
NotStan said:

Games missing so far:

Kinect Adventures,

Left 4 Dead 2,

Fable 2,

Fable 3.

Those are just the games that you've purposely turned a blind eye to between the 1st and the 6th place on 360.

Suprisingly you've also missed out Uncharted: Drake's Fortune, I have no idea what the cap is at.. But the Drake's Fortune is 7th if you add it in.

First of all the games you mentioned are on the pc which doesn't make them exclusives

UC1 came out in 2007 get your facts straight and I am not gonna add Kinect adventures, Sports Champions e.t.c those kind of games



dsage01 on 18 March 2011
yo_john117 said:
Kynes said:

Why CGI should do them, when this guy was the one who made the first of this type? Let him cherry pick whatever he wants.

Cause CGI knows how to do them up right without cherry picking.


I do them my way he does it his way no way is wrong and do you know what cherry picking even means? I don't think so.



Around the Network
NotStan on 18 March 2011
dsage01 said:
NotStan said:

Games missing so far:

Kinect Adventures,

Left 4 Dead 2,

Fable 2,

Fable 3.

Those are just the games that you've purposely turned a blind eye to between the 1st and the 6th place on 360.

Suprisingly you've also missed out Uncharted: Drake's Fortune, I have no idea what the cap is at.. But the Drake's Fortune is 7th if you add it in.

First of all the games you mentioned are on the pc which doesn't make them exclusives

UC1 came out in 2007 get your facts straight and I am not gonna add Kinect adventures, Sports Champions e.t.c those kind of games


Yes I just checked the release date of 2008 was for platinum my bad in this case, L4D came out for PC too. Fable 2 is a 360 exclusive, I guess you're not rushing to add it taking into account that KA is probably one of the best selling exclusives on HD consoles, a full 8M ahead of Sports Championship if you do decide to add it. Interesting.



Disconnect and self destruct, one bullet a time.

ethomaz on 18 March 2011
dsage01 said:
First of all the games you mentioned are on the pc which doesn't make them exclusives

Fable II is exclusive... and Left for Dead not.

Check my list.

And what the other criteria? Because I see Kinect Sports but not see Reavy Rain or others... over 2M sales?



smroadkill15 on 18 March 2011

Why do you need to make another thread about the same crap that has been posted 4 times already? Plus your missing so many games for both consoles.  



dsage01 on 18 March 2011
smroadkill15 said:

Why do you need to make another thread about the same crap that has been posted 4 times already? Plus your missing so many games for both consoles.  


give me one example of a game I am missing other than games like kinect adventures or sports champions!

I enjoy doing this stuff and I posted this kinda of stuff 4 times ( comparing the exclusives all in a differnt way each time)



yo_john117 on 18 March 2011
dsage01 said:
yo_john117 said:
Kynes said:

Why CGI should do them, when this guy was the one who made the first of this type? Let him cherry pick whatever he wants.

Cause CGI knows how to do them up right without cherry picking.


I do them my way he does it his way no way is wrong and do you know what cherry picking even means? I don't think so.

Agreed...but one way is good and one way...not so much.

And yes you are cherry picking....only having the top 6 spots, not including games that should be in there, only having games from 2008 and on. 

Here's good way to do it.

Have the top 30 exclusives from 2007, top 20 from 2008, top 15 from 2009, and top 10 from 2010, then include ALL the respective exclusives to each console (unless you plan to add all consoles and the PC into the mix)

But I know you won't do that.....hmmm maybe I should.