I often hear people who claim that VGcharts are totally inacurate.  Can this site be trusted?  Or do they only make estimations?  The new Europe data especially seems suspicious.  I wonder what you guys think.

whats that, vgcharts? i only know vgchartz =(

We seem to be, there is alot of outside forums that think we give total BS numbers tho.

I mean, the PS3 haters, especially, claim that the Europe numbers are totally false. Is this true?

ask yourself this :

aren't the numbers created on VGcharts the same way all sales number are made?

vgchartz is very accurate for Hardware numbers, and fairly accurate for software sales in general, but like all statistical analysis on small datasets it has issues accurately tracking particular games (especially more niche market games).

Yes, all numbers here are estimates. All number from NPD are also estimates. Weekly Japanese number from various sources are estimates. Almost all monthly sales figures you see on the net are estimates as well. None are 100% correct.

they have some retail connections , and of that and some other info they make their data, right?

VGChartz changed a lot over the last year.  There will always be people who hate sales figures that don't agree with their biases, but the numbers here agree with those posted by the NPD, Chart Track and Media Create.  Stick around for a while and watch: VGChartz compares it to the big boys including the NPD on a monthly basis and data is corrected if it is off by too much (NPD numbers are typically within 10%, sometimes very close).

The fact is that the numbers on the front of the page are pretty accurate.  Some people don't like it.  They can say what they want.

You sure have balls to question the accuracy of this site when you make a statement like this.