Just finished 'The Painted Man' and I don't really know what to think of it. I felt that a lot of the basic plot was extremely basic, the whole demons thing was kinda meh, but I ended up getting over it. I also don't like how much the book jumps, I understand Brett needs to get the backstory of his main chracters down, but it seemed like certain parts of their lives dragged on for much longer than other more interesting parts. He also doesn't have that flair with his writing that Rothfuss does, it's good, but once again, generic.
I like the characters, I like the settings for the villagers and I enjoy the fact that his not scared to get messy at some points. What I liked the most was the ward system, it's like a gameplay mechanic, they have one cool device and they have to play out the story and get through their obstacles by just using that mechanic. Smart stuff.
Overall, the book doesn't start off very well and it doesn't end very well, but it's filled with some really amazing chapters. The back stories are all interesting and the author isn't afraid to go for the gruesome result or use new ideas. The book felt like the beginning to a series, which it is and it's something people should take into account. If your going to read and enjoy this book, then your going to have to buy the sequel to fully understand and enjoy the story the authors telling. I'll be picking up the sequel, because I now feel invested into the plot, but the investment had a copule of bumps before it felt worthwhile.