If Versus XIII were to come in 2011 I think it may have a shot. Though as of now it is a tie between Killzone 3 and Uncharted 3.

It's such a tight race. I think Uncharted 3 will take the crown, but I'm quite impressed with how multiplat games on consoles can hold up.

As of now it seems like Uncharted 3 is the winner. Out of the opening post Gears Of War 2 comes close. Killzone 3 doesn't impress me as I feel its art direction is weak, or not pleasing to my eye.

You missed Elder scrolls 5 and Mass effect 3

For me it will be Uncharted 3 or Skyrim and Rage at third place. KZ3 is technically great but I can't stand its choice of colors and graphics style.

Testosterone showdown.

You should add Deus Ex Human Revolution:

It's to close to call,but I do like uncharted's vibrant colors,but it's all subjective really. lol

I would have to say i think Uncharted 3 will end up winning. They seem to be taking the graphics very VERY seriously ^^

For second i think it will be between crysis 2 and killzone 2 (i have no idea which as they both constantly seem to be slagging each other off lol)

Anything but Uncharted 3, since it's entry is a screen from a pre-rendered video whereas the others are not.

Unless pre-rendered videos are ok now:

Mass Effect 3