I traded just cause 2,I personally thought that game was to big for it's own good. lol

Agreed

Just Cause 2 is just a huge open world, so it doesn't have many bugs

For fallout new vegas, It has big open world too but most important thing is its nonlinear story line and dynamic choices

Minecraft called XD seriously that games fucking massive O_O

@The Map charts, I'm surprised GW: Nightfall is that big in comparison to these other games. Though all of the GW realms are pretty massive.

umm Minecraft has the biggest maps. Its 3 times the size of Earth

and they are all different 

sure they are randomly generated but they are great maps

The flight simulator series feature the entire world with all airports and cities on it. Except there is a big wall at the poles and weird stuff happens when you try to fly there.

Weird that san andreas is only 1/14th the size of burnout paradise, and world of warcraft only 2/5th on that map. I guess if the horses could run 200 mph world of warcraft would feel a lot smaller.

You have to remember that it's a racing game though. San Andreas does like, a million things.

Nope.  But some people's attention spans can be too small...

J'King.  Yes, sometimes a game can be too big.

Now I like big games, but only where it makes sense and enriches the game.  So for me Fallout and Oblivion, for example, were fine - in fact I'd have liked them to be bigger, with the content a bit more spread out.

But, sometimes big can be too big where it just looses focus - Just Cause 2, while fun, arguably is too big for it's own good as others have noted.

My first reaction is heck no... I love how huge the worlds are... it's why I fell in love with Fallout... but on second thought... I suppose Just cause 2 huge would be too big. I think a limit/end would be something most people would want since there's so many games out there to be played, so little time and I imagine( depending on development time, if it's short) quality may be comprimised.

So yes... a game can be too big.