GT5 me thinks. It's a good game, but not what we all expected...

I question the sanity of anyone who says ME2 is over-rated. The game brings so many new ideas to the table and did SO MUCH right that it can't be considered over-rated.

It's the first RPG that really made me rethink what RPGs should be since... oh, I don't know, Fallout 2 or maybe KOTOR? That's some damned impressive company.

In a year chock full of recycled content (Reach, GoWIII, FFXIII, GT5), there's plenty of material to complain about being over-rated without going after one of the more innovative and interesting titles of the entire year.

Lol, one of my old graveyard threads.

Please read the OP before you start saying things that don't make sense.

Fallout New Vegas

Bayonetta

Assassin's Creed Brotherhood

Call of Duty Black Ops

Halo Reach

...and that's about it.

Mass Effect 2 easily. I think it's a pretty good game, but I do not understand how it's at all considered for Game of the Year. Not even close to that caliber of game.

I played  Valkyria  Chronicles in 2010 - it was very probably that.

Dragon Age....

How can it be game of the year....

if ur talking 2011 its crysis 2 hands down......

halo reach and neir