By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General Discussion - VGC Mafia Round 22 Game Thread

Found the post: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3742110



Around the Network

The trouble with a Mafia game of this size is the inevitable huge number of idlers.

There are a good six of them. FoS them all.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

I do not suspect theProf at all



Linkzmax said:

Found the post: http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=3742110

Why did he bring my name up? Probably a typo - I was siding with him.

Of course, he makes a fair point, and you haven't yet been absolved of all guilt. Certainly, you're not the most suspicious person in the game, but you're up there.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Kantor said:

The trouble with a Mafia game of this size is the inevitable huge number of idlers.

There are a good six of them. FoS them all.


hmm?

which six?

I dont think I have been that inactive, I try to post whenever im about this game.

 



Around the Network

My top three are hephaestos, SAK, and kantor

Heph is fighting very strongly for the nameless townie situation. He came in to defend linkzmax by saying he also had no name, and then when linkz cleared up that he was only inferring what therepublic was saying, suddenly heph was the only vanilla without a name. 

Kantor seems very cautious and mentioned "sailor moon names" as well, and could have been a slip. Conversely, therepublic, who called kantor out on it, made just a very very cautious poke when he brought the post in question up. His post came off to me as "so, does this make anyone want to vote for kantor?". So, FoS on both of them. (more on therepublic, than kantor)

SAK asked a metagame question just like truck did, which in itself is scummy. However, he never really pursued any followup to it.  To me, mafia are the type to dip their toes in the water and leave it at that. The way he brought up lynching lurkers was very similar to that. Additionally, he was the second person to bring up meta-rules, and that comes off to me as an imitation of contributing (thanks to linkz for pointing that out).

 

Also guys, I really need to point something out too. Linkzmax recent post, was, well...dubious. I highly question his GoW assertion for several reasons. 1) His actions did not come off as scummy at all. That would have been total amateur mafia, and I think linkz would have understood that. However, I'll give him the benefit of the doubt because he doesn't know our players and their experience.

Secondly, making an entire case against GoW DURING THE NIGHT tells me a couple things, and I'll put them in the way I understand it.

A) He wants me to think that he's productive.
B) He wants me to think that he's suspicious of GoW
C) He wants me to think that when he wrote it, GoW is still in the game.

From looking at the way linkzmax plays, it seems like he has a lot of experience, and I wouldn't put it past him that what he wrote up above is a cover. Additionally, republic has posted a lot, and yet he somehow has no read. 

 

For now, I'm voting Heph.

Vote: Hephaestos



I thought Heph claimed to be a townie rather than haivng "no" name?



Homer_Simpson said:
Kantor said:

The trouble with a Mafia game of this size is the inevitable huge number of idlers.

There are a good six of them. FoS them all.


hmm?

which six?

I dont think I have been that inactive, I try to post whenever im about this game.

 

You're among the more inactive ones.

Your inactivity back in the Final Fantasy round led me to suspect you early on, and only a stupid mistake on my part reduced that suspicion. And you did turn out to be scum. So my eye is on you especially.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective

Homer_Simpson said:

I do not suspect theProf at all


so him calling for vanilla townies with names to come forward is ok with you?

Him "knowing" that vanilla townies have names as his argument is ok with you?

Gow unvoting then 10 lines later voting, pretty much showing he's one of the named townies, and then ending up dead because of prof's plan (which he revealed willingly when khuut said there won't be enough vanilla... again, why do so?) is ok with you?

 

please homer, tell us why you don't suspect him and if you don't, why you wouldn't suspect me? Cause for all intent and purposes, his and kuut's stance yesterday were pretty opposed to mine. Except that my defence of nonames hasn't gotten the doctor killed (little difference there).

 



OoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoOoO

theprof00 said:

 

Kantor seems very cautious and mentioned "sailor moon names" as well, and could have been a slip. Conversely, therepublic, who called kantor out on it, made just a very very cautious poke when he brought the post in question up. His post came off to me as "so, does this make anyone want to vote for kantor?". So, FoS on both of them. (more on therepublic, than kantor)

 

Oh, enough about the Sailor Moon names! I didn't properly read the sign-up thread, and I was surprised to see "Queen Beryl" right there in the opening posts's flavour text. That's all there is to it. I acknowledge my mistake: we, the subjects of Queen Beryl, are the town, and those damnable Sailor Senshi are the Mafia.

It's odd, the more I defend prof, the more he seems to attack me.



(Former) Lead Moderator and (Eternal) VGC Detective