Haters got to hate :P

good game dtewi. I would have had enjoyed it more if I actually had a laptop. But it was fun. 

Not the towns fault that it was filled with idiots. The game was easily winnable, you guys just suck 

MVP AWARD

theprof00

Easy choice. Everyone else was either horrible or okay. Prof played magnificently, and even survived for a while longer with the odds against him.

SHIT! I'M AN IDIOT AWARD

Godofwar

The person who made the biggest screwup. A fair few of you deserve this award, but it goes to Godofwar. Being scum, he should have exercise more caution with roleclaims. By roleclaiming Locke and saying Heph had a kill power, he basically killed himself... yet you guys didn't lynch him. I wonder why.

WORST CHOSEN NIGHT ACTIONS

Metalgear

dsister and radishhead were contenders, but it goes to metalgear. Not only did he choose scum, he also protected theRepublic which basically locked his victory.

MOST HELPFUL TOWNIE

Stefl

Honestly, not one townie lynched any scum of their own accord. No one was able to put one ounce of logic forth and deduce who might be scum and lynch them. Stefl gets this for being the only person to kill scum.

MOST HARMFUL TOWNIE

Kantor

I was seriously considering this for a second. Kantor vehemently lynched dsister which was a terrible move. He ignored some evidence that exonerated dsister and just pursued him. He did kill nen, but in actuality, anyone would have targeted nen. theRepublic targeted nen. He then tried to kill theRepublic, but that backfired. With the worst lynch I have ever seen, he gets this award.

MOST CONVOLUTED THINKER

theprof00

Does this need clarification? He rattled off about 20 paragraphs of stuff every night. He even assumed there was a watcher/tracker and targeted Homer. Very convoluted stuff right there.

SIMPLEST THINKER

The Town

I can't decide. None of you looked into the game. Hatmoza did a little, so he's excluded from this award, as is Final-Fan, but honestly, it's undecidable.

LURKER

dsister

How many posts did he make? 20?

BLATANT SCUM

Godofwar

I mean, he was so blatant I thought you guys would lynch him right away. Doom sapping his HP!? What the hell is that? Steal using MP? Honestly, poor understand of FF game mechanics, a horrible roleclaim, and you guys still didn't lynch him. You even struggled with a choice for the daykills when Nen and GoW were so completely obvious choices. Thank god you chose them, or I might have had a stroke.

THE SPORTSMANSHIP AWARD

Heph

I think you guys were just pissed the SK got too much power. If I didn't include an SK and made a fifth scum, then the town wouldn't be as powerful. At least one person didn't berate me and recognized that there were good elements in the game. Heph was definitely a good spirit, and didn't even hate you guys when you lynched him.

WORST PLAYER

The Town

Like hell I could choose from all of you. I'm sorry if I've been ranting, but you guys played so poorly. I can't even go into too much detail about how badly you played or I might spend half the night ranting. I sincerely hope not to see such dreadful playing in the future with you guys.

Let me put it this way.

I would cheer if some of you were scum next game.

I humbly accept this award

I sucked at choosing who to protect

You're the besst!

Honestly, I think the game worked out more like you thought it did than it could have. The only factors affecting it were nen and gow being so utterly scummy. Otherwise, there indeed would have been a lot more town lynching town.

I think the most significant factor, as you pointed out, was that town acted and thought so simply and superficially that it affected the suspicions. I mean, an unkillable doctor should normally be a blatant lie. As I understand it, it was in your design to give these roles in order to provoke a lynch. To me that makes sense. I would have lynched him even if I were town. 

There was a good base, and good structure/foundation to the gameplay that affected it badly. I think if we had played even marginally better, the things that seemed stacked against us, would've have seemed to impossible.

Here's an example. Vette used his power to ask how many of the people listed were lying. Had Homer or I roleclaimed earlier, we would have been included in the list, and his result would have been 1, which would have basically been a complete waste. These kinds of things are not predictable though.

Also you should make a category for "best stab in the dark"

My contenders would be:

1) Darth

On day 1 he actually called my role randomly, and PERFECTLY.

"I smell poison on those

You trying to kill me theprof00? my pet dog called Jerryanaki smelt the poison from a mile off dude!! shesh"

2) Metalgear

"Hello Aerith"

to which j0 sufficiently "freaked" out about.

So I have a question too...did metalgear block the night kill on therepublic??!? SHEESH

And the day that I started posting I was lynched >.> 

Don't take anything I say personally. As SnakeEyez puts it, "I'm a gracious loser." I just talk shit. I don't really mean the things I say. Except for the the unlynchable SK, It really was a great game!

What evidence? Every bit of evidence pointed towards dsister being scum! Every bit! He was lurking like crazy, he supposedly roleblocked the same person twice despite the fact that they were clearly a vanilla townie... Could we have made a better lynch? Definitely. Could we have made a worse lynch? Definitely. Was dsister the most suspicious person in the town on that day? Definitely. He was more suspicious than Homer, Prof and Republic combined. And, of course, if we had lynched Republic, nothing would have happened, if we had lynched Homer, two of us would have died. Prof was basically begging us to lynch him, and as you've admitted and I accept, he played brilliantly, so there was no way he was getting lynched then.

Honestly, prof, you ruined everything for yourself on that last day. Victory was in sight for you.

EDIT: Oh, and lynching Heph was a fair bit worse than lynching dsister

*hits Kantor in the back of his head with a shovel AGAIN*

Only with more game experience will you realize the mistakes you've made this game.

Holy shit!

I was actually right about Cloud being a puppet???

LOOOOOOOOOOOOOLZZZZ