well my fav Sonic games were the old Genesis ones so no, leave it that way

Not to derail or anything but I really hope Sonic Team gets it right with Sonic Colors. From what I've seen so far it looks like they have gone back to the roots this time so I say it has the potential to become the best Sonic game in a very long time. Maybe reaching the awsomeness of Genesis Sonic!? *knocks wood*

Short cutscenes like 2-3 minutes or i get annoyed and i hate unskippable cutscenes.

No CGI, that's for sure.

Everything should be told in the game engine, and there should be very little, if any dialogue.

They should do the cutscenes like they did them in S3&K, told while you progress the game, like this.

I'm the odd one out in thinking that Sonic Unleashed was an amazing game (Haven't played Sonic since the genesis) and I actually enjoyed the cutscenes in the game, so as long as they balance out it with the gameplay I don't see why they shouldn't add it to the experience.

PS: Sonics on the HD consoles as well.