spdk1 said: For those asking why there hasn't been a group of people who see the OT God as evil, there already is/was. a group that originally was around before Christianity called the Gnostics had this view. There are Many many subsets of this group, as it is more of a philosophy than a religion in many cases. They believed that the OT God was an imperfect creator and the real god was infinitely perfect, and never really spoke to anyone or actually had anything to do with humans. Some modern Gnostic thinkers relate this god to the universe or a mental construct of what it means to be good etc... The Orthodox (Catholic) heresey hunters of the early Christian faith persecuted the Gnostics and tried to stamp them out completely, but some of their teachings persist. |
The early Christian church, if you speak second century onward, wasn't even large enough to do any sort of large scale persecution of gnostics. If anything, it was a sparring of words and writings. What you do find, in the Catholic church, is they have the tendency to document everything, and store it. They don't stamp out considered heretical teaching, but label it and treat it as a disease, and then come up with lines of arguments against it. In short, it has a name and a description of why it is error. And this is used to build a theological system.
In regards to gnostic teaching, there are issues with a number of it. Part of it is that gnostics have an alergy to matter, and think matter is evil. Christ being God incarnate seems to be offensive, because the material world doesn't matter at least, if not evil. This is an assault on the incarnation (denial of Christ as God incarnate, and also denying Christ came in the flesh). They also have a general rule of believing salvation comes through right knowledge. If I was going to critique evangelical theology, it is their tendency to put belief, not as trusting in God/Christ, but believe certain things true, that ends up being like gnosticism. The denial of the flesh and the material world, is a dangerous thing on a lot of levels. It leads to people not doing good deeds, and not manifesting love in any form. It also has people not take ownership over their own body and their own lives, because they don't believe it matters. You see the letters of John write on this, about how denial of Christ coming in the flesh, is of the spirit of the Anti-Christ. Paul writes a lot of about love in the letters also.
Another aspect of gnosticism, particularly the teaching on how the Old Testament God was not the real God, is that a leading person preaching that, decided to come up with what was considered "True" scripture, and selectively took some of Paul's writings, and some of the gospel accounts. They also threw out the Old Testament. This drove the conventional Christians to counter, and led to the eventual formation of a New Testament canon in response.
I think we may be nearing the end here. Carry on. I have other things I need to get to now.