Microsoft
Presentation 4: What a joke, too focused on Kinetic and so many akward moments with the games and "exercises", Kojima's presentation was too short and the info on Gears 3 and Fable 3 wasn't enought (plus I really dislike the direction of Fable 3)
Games 6: 4 big titles (and yes we know about the multiplat) nothing really new, and the worst thing is Rare's debacle making a Wii Sports ripoff.
Trailers 5: New Halo and Gears are great. I was really disspoiting for Fable 3 hated the "military" theme on it, about Kinetic Trailers, bleh.
SCORE: 5, best luck next time.
Nintendo
Presentation 9: WOW, they really improve this after 2008 disaster and 2009 underwhelming conference, this year was great every person on stage showed real passion for their products and even with the techical issues on the Zelda game it was a fun, gaming oriented conference.
Games 9: For me the real surprise wasn't DKC or Zelda. It was the amazing lineup for the 3DS, I haven't seen such a good selection of titles for a new console since the SNES days, some titles were really unexpected like MGS3, SSFIV and RE (I suppose that the PSP has been canceled)
Trailers 9: Kid Icarus and DKC were cool, Zelda was a bit of underwhelming in my opinion but some of the previews are quite possitive about the title.
Score 9, good Ninty you've been redemed from the turd 2008 was.
Sony
Presentation 8: I really like the last part of the conference, but I didn't dig the Move and Plus parts Kevin Butler was good but not as I expected, one of the elemets that took away some of the shock value was that almost every games showed in the conference was announced days ago .
Games 9: So we have finally a date for GT 5, and Twisted Metal looks good even if it isn't my favorite game. Unfortunally there was a big ausence here ........ where is The Last Guardian?
Trailers 8: Same as before, most of the stuff here was showed before. Sony needs to stops the leaks for the next E3.
Score 8.3 Good but could be a lot better.
