I hope the Agent plays in the same league. Together with LA Noir Rockstar could really become better then ever.

yeah it's fucking great, or should I say it was fucking great ?
I finished it a few hours ago and I was VERY sad when it ended..... ah well there's still a lot of things to do :)
So far my 7th favourite game of this gen.

GTAIV only fault was having nothing to do with the money earned, unlike San Andreas but it was still a phenomenal game. It actually increased my respect for Rockstar and RDR just made things better.

GTA IV was just the starting point for this gen like GTA III. I think they've learned from some of their mistakes. Next GTA will be the real deal

RDR is one of my favorite games. Full stop.

I just feel bad for AW such a potentail title got blown away by these awesome game

Yeah they did what Call of Juarez couldn't do make a great western game.

damn i really wanna play this game

I liked GTA IV so I'll love this game, it's on the way to my home right now from Amazon.

Ok, I'm liking it a little less now that I've got to Armadillo. The horse riding is fine, the gunplay is a little shallow and generic though. I'm digging the main character, he kinda sounds flat though, like Bill Paxton.

The story so far seems a tad predictable. Also, I think I've encountered a bug(the game did freeze on me, but that's not what I'm talking about). I did the "question mark" subquest for the woman outside the sheriffs office, tracked down the "clue" and the game said something about "the story isn't over yet" so I went back to where she was before and she was gone, wtf?

Also, the skyline graphics are some of the most beautiful I've seen in a game.

I started at a 9.5/10, it's dropped down to an 8.5 right now(after the freeze) but I think it'll pick back up.