XiaoMay said: @ BW-Jp : would be more like this :
Production values: Bayonetta of course ! Scale (?) : what's that ? Graphics: GoW 3, ok... Presentation: (Yeah, graphics, presentation, outlook etc, same stuff), we know, GoW looks "better" (in fact I prefer Bayonetta) Story: Bayonetta of course !!! Music: Bayonetta again Gameplay: Comparable : GoW is basic, Bayonetta is fantastic Controls: Here again, GoW is just more of the same, when Bayonetta is giving the whole HnS genre a new intensit. But let's call it a tie.
and you forgot : Originality : Bayonetta Replay Value : Bayonetta
...
|
Production value: God of War 3
Scale (how "large" the game makes you feel while playing it): God of War 3
Graphics: Hands down, God of War 3
Presentation: If you take everything and put it together. Is it a full package deal? God of War 3 surely is, but Bayonetta is very close on this one in fact its almost a tie.
Story: okay, come on. Bayonetta's story is just ridiculous. God of War 3's story however is incredible because the narrative of Krato's revenge spans three games with the conclusion being the third. It's just that good.
Music: hmmm, lets see here. Uper-awesome opera compared to anime music. I'll let you guys decide. This one is a matter of opinion.
Gameplay: Well, thats a tough one because again they are pretty evenly matched. Yes, Bayonetta is more fluid, and you can perform much cooler combos.
Originality: God of War 3, hands down. Bayonetta is based off of Devil May Cry's gameplay and art style.
Replay value: Why would you ever replay Bayonetta is beyond me. Unless you really enjoyed the game, then please go ahead and replay it as much as you can. But, in my opinion, I would replay God of War 3 over and over just because I wouldn't get bored after the first 5 minutes.