This game is looking to be one of the best of the year imo. What will it do sales-wise though? I will say 500k for 360 first week and 400k for ps3 first week...what about you?

its going to get marketed up the peehole you probably see advertisements for it on every single gaming website a few weeks before release and commercials will be a plenty its gonna sell over a mill first week easily

this... ^^

I agree. This game has the potential to be one of the biggest games of the year. Plus the marketing behind this game will be strong. So with that being said :

Xbox 360 : 800 K World Wide

PS3 : 650 K World Wide

i will getting this first day i just been too lazy to go pre order it

360: 500k first week

PS3: 15 million first week since GT5 is canceled and all of that game's first week sales transfer over to RDR

i c wat u did there

I hope 5 million lifetime between PS360, but that's probably too much.

Maybe a 1 million opening week then. 600K on X360 and 450K on PS3.

Very hard to say. It wont reach GTA4 sales, not even close, but perhaps top 10 this year, maybe top 5.

Prediction:

PS3 - first week: 900k
X360 - first week: 900k

PS3 - lifetime: 4.2 million
X360 - lifetime: 3.8 million

TOTAL: 8 million

I hope this game sells well.. it looks awesome.