I excluded the Orange box, because of Half-life 2, but if you feel that this is the best game of this generation so far then by all means pick other and post your thoughts. I also put these games up based on there metacrtic score, you don't have to agree because god knows I don't so pick any game from the big three that you think is the best. I personally belive the best game so far is a tie between Mass Effect 2 and Final Fantasy XIII. Also if you can not choose just one like I am unable to then try to limit yourself to two!

Okay this is my first poll so people lets vote!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Of those I picked Mass Effect 2, but I actually prefer the first Mass Effect.

OTHER.

Once again you not limited to just those you can pick other and just type the name of that title in!

GOW III and MGS 4.

Other = Fallout 3 for me.

uncharted 2

GTA IV is so over rated.
You already heard it a thousand times. You should hear it two thousand times more.

OTHER

I dont think it was severely over-rated.......we were promised the absolute god in gaming judging by the reviews and all we got was great....dissapointing yes but it was absolutely worth $60 and thats all that matters.

@OP

Other for me as well.....out of the list I would choose ME2 but my fav of the gen is Bayonetta.