Is Playstation Move an Improvement over Wii-Remote? | |||
| Yes, very much so. | 46 | 35.94% | |
| Yes, somewhat. | 31 | 24.22% | |
| No. | 50 | 39.06% | |
| Total: | 127 | ||
I have no idea until I've tried it and the same goes for everyone else in here. Up until we've played a decent game with it its all juts speculation.
I am leaning more towards "no" though.
| Damnyouall said: Now that we have established that Sony's motion controller is not a ripp-off of Nintendo's Wii Remote (a prototype was demonstrated as early as 2004, long before Wii http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JbSzmRt7HhQ ), I'd like to ask: Do you think Playstation Move is an improvement over Wii Remote which will make new kinds of games possible? |
In that video, I only see a ball with a stick. No accelerators, no gyroscopes, no wand shaped controller, no nunchuck, no wrist band...
Just a camera detecting a ball.
| Mummelmann said: I have no idea until I've tried it and the same goes for everyone else in here. Up until we've played a decent game with it its all juts speculation. I am leaning more towards "no" though. |
Well now in fairness I don't think anyone is trying to say it necessarily provides better experiences than the Wii Remote, which would be a ludicrous thing to say. It just looks like - based on what we've seen so far - that the tech is there.
Khuutra said:
Well now in fairness I don't think anyone is trying to say it necessarily provides better experiences than the Wii Remote, which would be a ludicrous thing to say. It just looks like - based on what we've seen so far - that the tech is there. |
I know, but tech alone doesn't make it an improvment unless the entire concept gets taken seriously and is backed by the big dogs making software. I guess what I'm trying to say is, as is the case with Natal; I need to see good quality game efforts with full and funcionally sound implementation of the tech to judge whether or not the whole thing is just a waste.
From what I'm seeing, it'll be primarily casual fare with little to no depth and it just makes the whole thing look like Carnival games HD and utterly useless imo (Socom does little to redeem it imo).
why did you make another thread? your other thread is about the same topic.
- Wasteland - The Mission.
| Mummelmann said: I know, but tech alone doesn't make it an improvment unless the entire concept gets taken seriously and is backed by the big dogs making software. I guess what I'm trying to say is, as is the case with Natal; I need to see good quality game efforts with full and funcionally sound implementation of the tech to judge whether or not the whole thing is just a waste. From what I'm seeing, it'll be primarily casual fare with little to no depth and it just makes the whole thing look like Carnival games HD and utterly useless imo (Socom does little to redeem it imo). |
Well, I'm not going to make judgment on that front - they do have a lot of promised support from major developers, but there was a time where that was true for the Wii, too.
When it comes to whether or not Move was worth it, I agree, we'll need to actually see some games released and see how they play. I just assumed this was about the tech.
| Buzzi said: Over Wii-remote yes, over Wii Motion Plus not much, and considering you can buy Wii Mote + Nunchuk + Wii Motion Plus for 60$ (on Amazon) while the PS Move starter kit (maybe without its version of nunchuck) will cost 80-90$. Probably is a compact version of the Wii Remote with 1:1 (or near) movement, but I think his problem will be the price, and the fact that the most selling games don't need it. |
they are costing the same actually, camera price it's 40$. and bundle includes all 3 things for 100$
and if u have camera u dont have to pay for it.
and PS move support augmented reality (that gotten really popular with nokia, android, and iphone) recently the wii doesn't, a better z detection.
| Khuutra said: Technically speaking, yes. Almost definitely. I don't think there are many things the Wiimote can do that the Move can't. |
No. The problem of Move is the pointer-controls. Move has a big lag there, because of technically limitations, it is almost unusable for Shooters.
The motion controls are equally.
z101 said:
No. The problem of Move is the pointer-controls. Move has a big lag there, because of technically limitations, it is almost unusable for Shooters. The motion controls are equally. |
Well now I said "many thing", not "any things". I haven't been keeping u with the impressions for the past day or so, I admit it. Is the lag for the pointer really that bad?
Lol seems pretty even:
| Is Playstation Move an Improvement over Wii-Remote? | |||
| Yes, very much so. | 10 | 33.33% |
|
| Yes, somewhat. | 10 | 33.33% |
|
| No. | 10 | 33.33% |
|
| Total: | 30 |
About Us |
Terms of Use |
Privacy Policy |
Advertise |
Staff |
Contact
Display As Desktop
Display As Mobile
© 2006-2026 VGChartz Ltd. All rights reserved.
