=/ I still disagree, it is the 4th best game of all time.. right behind Half-Life 2, Zelda OoT and Mario 64. Mario 64 would have been higher if it was rated by 4 more reviewers at that time.

WOW Gratz SMG. You're the first game that may challenge OoT.

Also, no one's giving this below a 9 without getting ROFLed off the internet.

Galaxy is starting to feel like GOTY now. It's gonna be close. Bioshock deserves it as well from the reviews.

If you throw temporal equal opportunities* away, Super Mario Galaxy is the best game ever due to having better graphics but no less gameplay than the other contenders.

*old games being rated considering their time's technology limitations.

did you guys notice official playstation magazine gave this game a 10

So far I have only had one hour with this game. It is amazing. I really like it. I can tell this will be a game that gets played over and over and one of the very few games I don't resell.

Yeah, it's that good.

Big, enormous irony that it's not counted towards average on GR.

The link leads you to GameTap

actually it does count but only in the score thats in brackets

Wow it's still in the running to be number 1 ever. 2 more perfect scores and it's already there. Seems very likely.
I'm not worried about Zelda loosing it's throne, Mario is the king of gaming... untill another Zelda claims back the throne!
One more night and I can play this wonder myself :D

I mean, you know I love you right? Really I do but...

Zelda as best game EVER!?

Kirby Super Star is so offended. And video gaming as a whole should shun you for forgetting how amazing Chrono Trigger was. Hell, even Mario 64 and Ogre Battle 64 were better N64 games (of course, this is my opinion).